Tom,
Interesting view on Pine Valley and one which I think would work. If we can limit crowds to a manageable amount and balance the income with TV money the whole experience would probably be a lot better. I think, however, there may be a problem. In this country the income at the gates is often that which is passed on to the club and the TV income goes to the Tour.
Given the apparent greed of our Pros and Tour Officials it may be difficult to negotiate settlements.
I would also add that limited crowds would be easier to control. We could perhaps eradicate the ridiculous hoopin an Hollerin and YOOOO Da MAAAN and other such inane pish and drivvel.
I think the addition of Hoylake may also be a problem. As I recall it was considered in the 60s but even then struggled to cope with the advances of time. If it were lengthened and toughened would it still be 'Hoylake'?
Brian,
What are the detrimental effects on Nairn. I was up there earlier in the year and it looked exactly the same to me as it always has. Beautifully kept, fantastic greens, and the modernised club house is a gem. Even the Pro shop is still where it was in Gregor McIntosh's days.