Notts Golf Club
The year 1901 was surely a grand one for Willie Park Junior in that three of his most heralded courses opened: The Old Course at Sunningdale, his beloved Huntercombe and in November, the Hollinwell course in Nottinghamshire. Few architects have three such outstanding courses to their entire resume, let alone the same year! Famous for his untiring work ethic, Park may have worked himself to death, at least according to some historians. Regardless, these three designs at the start of the twentieth century established Park as the preeminent golf course architect for what would become known as the Golden Age of Golf Course Architecture.
Park’s great strength was his ability to route a course and to use the ground contours to maximum effect. He didn’t believe in the prolific use of man-made hazards (i.e. bunkers) and others bunkered his work. In the case of Notts, J.H. Taylor was called in the following year and much of Notts existing bunkering schemes are his work. (Later, Taylor returned the favor to Park: When Taylor was awarded the contract to build Aldeburgh in Suffolk, he commissioned Park to route the course which Taylor then bunkered).
In 1912, the final significant piece of the puzzle fell into place when Tom Williamson, the golf professional at Notts from 1896 til his death in 1950 (!), built three new holes on the west side of the entrance drive. These holes (today’s first through third) replaced several hilly holes past today’s thirteenth tee and to the left of the ninth green. Thanks to Williamson, the final eighteen playing corridors were now in place. By 1934, the course measured 6,720 yards and by 1981, it measured over 7,000, a sure sign of the club’s long standing intent to host big events. Today, it measures 7,250 yards and is capable of hosting any event it wishes. In 2012, it will host the Boy’s Championships and it is one of the few Golden Age courses that can handle the prodigious distances that the fellows now hit it.
As the course is located near Nottingham, the visitor cannot help but conjure up images of Robin Hood’s Sherwood Forest. However, Notts does not play through a forest but features markedly varied terrain which was extremely well utilized by Park and Williamson. It has holes that are heathland in character (e.g., the fourth and fifth), holes of a wooded nature (e.g., the seventh and eighth) and holes that attack the hills (e.g., the twelfth, thirteenth and fifteenth). Despite these different ‘looks,’ the course holds together well as one entity and not several different fragments.
One charming aspect of Notts is that the course is home to several different species of gorse, one of which is always in bloom, adding a fine touch of color to the landscape. For those who always seem to miss Dornoch or County Down at the ‘right’ time of year, you can appreciate how nice this feature is.
Another interesting aspect is the presentation of its bunkers which predominately feature grass rolled down at least half the bunker face. The ninth is an instructive hole relative to the presentation of its bunkers. Unlike Ganton and Woodhall Spa, the bunkers do not dominate the player’s perception of the course. The grass faced bunkers, though invariably well placed, don’t confront the golfer with a sea of sand. Rather, the golfer is left to admire the magnificent property.
Holes to Note
Second hole, 460 yards; After a mild opening, the course quickly establishes its muscle. This attractive, uphill dogleg left finishes with its green in front of the rock known as ‘Robin Hood’s Chair’ in a cleft between two large, pine-covered hills. Drive to the outside of the dogleg and the golfer can see the green. Drive too far to the outside and the golfer can’t reach the green! The approach is well done, with a bunker guarding the front-right corner of the green and plenty of room on the left to bounce in the long approach to the left-to-right sloping green.
Third hole, 545 yards; The sleeper of the course, this short par five heads back to the clubhouse. From the elevated tee, the hole appears broad and encourages the big hitter to open his shoulders. The fun begins when the player is at that do-I-or-don’t-I spot for his second. Many a player who is undecided will try to compromise and play short-right of the green, wisely away from the entrance drive (which is not out of bounds) and bunkers on the left, he thinks. His only concerns are carrying the bunker some 65 yards short of the green and the right rough. However, he will soon realize he has been played the fool, for he now faces a short pitch over (or through) the slightest of swales to the right of the green and a pitch to the green from an awkward angle. He will now wish he had laid up short of the two left bunkers, from where he would have a longer but more straightforward approach.
Fourth hole, 455 yards; Played away from the clubhouse, this was the first hole in Park’s routing. Of the five longest par fours on the course, four feature distinctly uphill tee shots with the forward progress of the tee ball often deadened by the hillside. Coupled with approach shots that are also uphill, holes like the second, fourth, and fifteenth play even longer than the card suggests.
Sixth hole, 580 yards; When Park designed the course, this playing corridor housed a par four followed by a par three situated near today’s green site. Williamson converted the two holes into the three shotter that it is today and utilized the rolling topography to perfection. The ideal tee ball carries the crest of the hill and enjoys a huge kick forward, hopefully bringing the green within reach in two.
Eighth hole, 410 yards; The site of the famous ‘Holy Well,’ from whence Hollinwell derives its name and a sure sign that this isn’t ‘just another course.’ After the intimidating drive across the water and between the trees, the player should be sure to go down into the ‘well,’ take the metal cup fixed to a chain and sample the water himself. The approach is also quite inviting, with the left-to-right slope of the green.
Tenth hole, 415 yards; After holing out at the turn, the golfer walks through a row of trees to reach the tenth tee. From there, he looks out to a fairway with more abrupt movement than what he has seen previously. Indeed, he won’t see his tee ball land and the next five holes take the golfer on a grand counterclockwise loop, covering the most rambunctious terrain on the property. So starts one of the finest nine hole stretches in golf, inland or otherwise, as the golfer will be challenged to play a variety of herioc and creative shots.
Twelfth hole, 475 yards; The club best described this hole in its centenary pamphlet: ‘The worst or the best hole on the course is perhaps the 12th – according to the wind. Wind against – a great hole; wind behind – well, we cannot have it both ways.’ The hole plays along a high ridge and, approximately 170 yards from the green, the fairway drops off and to the left sharply, leaving the player who drives it there an awkward blind shot from a sloping stance. Yet, from around the 185 yard mark, the approach is one of the most fun shots on the course with the player using the high ground to the right of the green as a way to bank his approach onto the putting surface.
Thirteenth hole, 240 yards; Notts is best known for this dramatic, downhill par three, which surely rivals the thirteenth at The Addington as the best long one shotter in inland British golf. Justly famous, this hole owes its creation to Williamson. The son of the station master at Bulwell Forest, Tom started caddying at age seven at the original Burwell site for Notts in the late 1880s. It says a lot about both Notts and Williamson that each found the others company satisfactory for over half a century! Since the distance on the thirteenth is quite taxing, especially exposed to the wind, Williamson gave the player enough room short and right of the green. However, this ‘safety’ zone cannot be believed until after several rounds as that area is largely hidden from the tee, partly by trees and partly by gorse. In difficult conditions, the player who is playing conservatively, therefore, will have to fire his tee shot off toward what looks to be most unfriendly country. Much more than just a pretty hole.
Fifteenth hole, 440 yards; The favorite hole of some, this brute would be at home at Royal County Down. The narrow green with its 17 yard wide entrance is cruelly one of the smallest on the course and is set against and surrounded by what looks suspiciously like gorse-covered sand dunes. In fact, the player expects that he would catch a glimpse of the sea if he scaled them, only to be reminded by his friend that they are about as far removed from the sea as any spot in England.
Sixteenth hole, 355 yards; From another elevated and exposed tee, the player plays down and (perhaps) to the right. This can be a fearsome proposition into the wind as there is nearly a 200 yard carry to the fairway. The green is quite wide but shallow (20 yards) and is perched atop a fearsome bunker. (There is also a wall of gorse behind the green that provides for more than just scenery – have you ever thinned a wedge from the fairway?) The front left of the green features the most slope of any putting surface on the course, befitting a hole of this length. The hole’s beauty lies in how each golfer is free to determine for himself the best way to play it.
Eighteenth hole, 460 yards; Though many of the par fours play gradually up some sort of slope, both the sixteenth and eighteenth feature intoxicatingly attractive downhill views and tee shots. The clubhouse with its chimneys and warm glow emanating from within makes for an attractive backdrop.
Two characteristics that Notts possesses that some other inland gems do not are length and difficulty. While such factors are not prerequisites for top courses, having them has never hurt a course. The inland courses of England seem to fall into two groups – the courses near London and the few top-notch ones that are scattered throughout the country (e.g., Woodhall Spa and Ganton). Notts has advantages over both. It possesses the length that several of the top London courses lack; it finishes well, unlike Woodhall Spa; and it has the variety that some of the courses, such as Ganton, lack. Even though it has twelve par fours, the variety in length, topography, shape, setting and pacing of the two-shotters at Notts holds the player’s interest so that he would never complain ‘Not another par four!’ People should beat a path to this course – it has it all.
Royal Cinque Ports Golf Club
Thirteenth hole, 420 yards; Variety of challenge is a- some say the – most appealing attribute for any design to possess. When analyzing a course for that potential quality, some look at the holes in their totality while others like to break up the one, two and three shotters and look at the pars separately. Whichever way is fine and in the case of the two shotters at Deal,the 1st and the 18thare bunkerless while 7th and here possess the most bunkers on the course with eight. Of all the bunkering patterns at Deal, the 13th is as appealing as any. Two large bunkers on the inside of the dogleg require a carry of 215 yards while three cross bunkers bisect the fairway 105 yards from the green. Which set of bunkers is more problematic shifts with whether the hole is into or downwind.
Fourteenth hole, 220 yards; Deal has hosted two Opens though floods and two World Wars prevented it from hosting three other ones. As one might imagine from a course that is highly sought to identify the best players, the ability to hit controlled long iron shots is a requirement. In an effort to keep the challenge of the course current with modern technology, the 14th has been lengthened by 25 yards since Deal was to host the (canceled) 1938 Open. Now as then, the player must punch a low boring long iron to a none too big target.
Fifteenth hole, 450 yards; Standing on the 15th tee, the golfer is in the heart of the original 1892 nine hole courseso he is not surprised to find ideal golfing terrain with random land movements of one to six feet from tee to green.
Sixteenth hole, 505 yards; Sir Peter Allen calls this ‘a hole in a million’ and surely either this hole or the 3rd would be included in any eclectic 18 hole compilation of the United Kingdom’s finest holes. Mark Rowlinson in The Globetrotter Golf Guide to England and Wales succinctly describes the challenge of the hole when he writesthat ‘from any distance the green is hard to hit and hold, perched as it is on a minor mountain.’
Seventeenth hole, 390 yards; Deal’s strong hold on Bernard Darwin is legendary and in part must be due to the fact that the sand dunes, ridges, and humps and hollows run throughout the course and especially in the fairways.Deal is at the other end of the spectrum from Royal Birkdale where the dunes mainly serve to frame the holes and the golf is generally played from flat fairways and level stances. At Deal, the golfer is always adjusting his stance and the 17th fairway is as roly-poly as any on the course. Vardon’s Palour is a basin down the the right of the fairway from where the flag can be seen; any drive left of center is likely to yield a blind approach. And just as the fairway is full of character, so too is the green complex where the natural folds in the ground around the green feed well into the putting surface. This wonderful penultimate hole leaves the golfer wishing that more holes of this length were played at this point in the round.
Eighteenth hole, 410 yards; Not as dramatic as the holes that immediately precede it, this becomes a very fine Home hole because of its raised kidney shaped green complex. Some approaches will catch the right edge of the green only to roll off the plateau and leave an interesting chip or putt back up the three foot slope. Other approaches may catch the bank and be kicked further from the green, leaving a very awkward recovery shot across flat ground to the raised green.
One thing’s for sure:as atThe Old Course at St. Andrews, to add to the pressure at the 18th green, prying eyes from the clubhouse window will be taking in all the action.
And speaking of the Old Course at St. Andrews, its influence on the evolution of Deal is evident. Like St. Andrews,the routing of Deal is of the out and back variety with a loop at the end, a burn guards the 1st green (which makes for an excellent 19th hole as well), the ground is not dramatic but it is full of wrinkles and creases into which bunkers were cut, and the green complexes are well and truly varied allowing the course to play equally well whether the wind is with or against on the way in. Deal has a famously strong finish like St. Andrews. Also, too, the author’s favorite single shot at Deal (the approach to the 15th) shares the attribute that St. Andrews possesses beyond all courses: a controlled shot to a green that runs away from the player. In the case of the 15th at Deal, the play is to miss the green long as the resulting return chip is none too difficult but like The Old Course at St. Andrews, getting to know the smart misses takes years and years.
Also, as at St. Andrews, the terrain flattens out for a few holes around the turn. However, like St. Andrews,the golf quality never suffers. Indeed, those who cite St. Andrews as their favorite course in the world are quick to point to the great merits of the dominate bunker at The Short hole at The Old Course or how the 10th green may be the course’s most perplexing. Similarly, one’s ultimate opinion of Deal likely depends largely on one’s thoughts regarding the merits of its first twelve holes, not its famous finishing stretch. The clever angles at Deal’s 10th and Braid’s excellent green complex at the 12th are but two examples of the course never losing its appeal and of maintaining a high standard throughout all eighteen holes.
With the round concluded, the golfer repairs to the bar on the second floor of one of the United Kingdom’s most attractive clubhouses, offering views across the English Channel to France. Thinking back over the day, who can fail to be impressed by how solid the eighteen holes are? Every hole is of appeal, from the rippling 1st green across the burn, to the crumpled 2nd fairway all the way along to the plateau 18th green. None of this is by accident and to peruse David Dobby’s Feature Interview on this site is to understand that much care and thought has gone into the evolution of these links. The enthusiasm with which Noel Freeman writes about Dealin Deal Me In! was echoed in every decade of the 20th century by various esteemed writers/players/critics.
To see Deal ranked #50 in the world in the 1939 publication of The National Golf Review as found by Tom MacWood is of no surprise. More is the pity is that golfers rush to play courses on the modern Open rot alike Royal Birkdale and Muirfield, not understanding that the historic links at Deal still offers a superior form of links golf to this day. In sum, to quote Mark Rowlinson again regarding Deal, ‘True, there are blind shots, short par 4s, and uneven fairways, the sort of thing deplored by some modern players, but they are appreciated and expected by connoisseurs of true links golf.’