The irony of this thread is the proposition of a “stale redundancy of excellence” atop the GCA food chain and perhaps that would be a bad thing.
It’s not real.
Let’s step away from the drafting table a bit. At least in the US, we have a long way to go with regard to the saturation of design excellence for the bulk of golfers. If there were 100 Originals each of C&C, Doak, Stranz, Hanse, DMKidd, King/Collins Rhebb/Johns Etc, this might hold more validity. A Hanse Match Trail would tasty. Devries and Foster munys… delicious.
Access to great GCA is rare, so to propose that the contemporary GCA+ pool has become “stale” or redundant is a bit of a stretch. There is no contemporary GCArchie with a high volume catalog akin to Ross’.
We wish there was a glut of great golf architecture but in reality, many retail golfers (granted, again, in the US) are playing circular greens with seed smuggled from the baseball outfield and off the black market from the Tackle/Helmet/football stadium.
(Ok that’s harsh but not too far off) Find some bunker sand to buy right now. Go ahead… I’ll wait…
Others have nice courses but there are still not enough. Our best publics are over sold and can be saddled with 5 and 6 hour rounds regardless if they are in urban or rural areas. We don’t have a very high GCA+/Golfer ratio.
Cirba and Bausch were at Jeffersonville with Ron Prichard and they learned that the Jeff was going to do 60,000 rounds in calendar 2021. 60k. We need more “GCA+” across-the-board to fulfill the demand. Sweetens is on a waitlist status, some Lawsonia tee times are sold into 2023 and you have between 06:00:00 am and 06:00:10 sec am to get a tee time at Houston Memorial.
On the high end, every top gca course weekend is likely sold out through 2022 and into 2023.
When we have a course by the aforementioned in every city, and I can ride a train town to town with my clubs on my back and play two a day, then maybe this proposed “similarity glut” is a thing. Ross is likely the closest GCArchie to have his own eco system.
When there is a Houston Memorial Park Golf, Goat Hill, Common Ground,George Wright, Lawsonia, Winter Park 9, Sweetens Cove, Tobacco Road, Jeffersonville or the like in every town, we still would have barely broken the surface of a demand for contemporary GCA excellence. And when the Covid bump levels out, GCA excellence will likely prevail.
Right now, we’re shouting in a very small room. I wish Stranz was overbuilt.