News:

Welcome to the Golf Club Atlas Discussion Group!

Each user is approved by the Golf Club Atlas editorial staff. For any new inquiries, please contact us.


jeffwarne

  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: Your year in golf so far
« Reply #100 on: October 26, 2018, 10:55:40 PM »
Durness
Valliere


Life is good
"Let's slow the damned greens down a bit, not take the character out of them." Tom Doak
"Take their focus off the grass and put it squarely on interesting golf." Don Mahaffey

Jim Tang

  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: Your year in golf so far
« Reply #101 on: October 27, 2018, 11:15:39 AM »

In chronological order.....

Bluejack National
Pelican Hill - North
Prairie Dunes
Mammoth Dunes
Sand Valley
Butterfield
North Shore
Horseshoe Bay
Shoreacres
Glen Club

Peter Pallotta

Re: Your year in golf so far
« Reply #102 on: October 27, 2018, 11:26:01 AM »
I've played about 6 new courses (i.e. for the first time) this year, none of them noteworthy, but as with last year and the year before that my 'year in golf' is mostly about trying to get better as a golfer. I hope one day soon to be decent enough to travel a bit to some of the great courses listed above and be able to meaningfully play & appreciate the architecture on offer. I think I'm close. Maybe one last new piece of modern technology will do it...



Joe Hancock

  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: Your year in golf so far
« Reply #103 on: October 27, 2018, 01:38:01 PM »
I've played about 6 new courses (i.e. for the first time) this year, none of them noteworthy, but as with last year and the year before that my 'year in golf' is mostly about trying to get better as a golfer. I hope one day soon to be decent enough to travel a bit to some of the great courses listed above and be able to meaningfully play & appreciate the architecture on offer. I think I'm close. Maybe one last new piece of modern technology will do it...
P


Oh please! I’ve played this lovely game with you, and you have every bit of understanding (maybe too much understanding, if anything) to enjoy any golf courses’ architecture. I’ll tell you what, I’ll block a couple days in 2019 to meet you somewhere that you would be interested in seeing. Just tell me when and where!
« Last Edit: October 27, 2018, 04:31:32 PM by Joe Hancock »
" What the hell is the point of architecture and excellence in design if a "clever" set up trumps it all?" Peter Pallotta, June 21, 2016

"People aren't picking a side of the fairway off a tee because of a randomly internally contoured green ."  jeffwarne, February 24, 2017

Jim Sitar

  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: Your year in golf so far
« Reply #104 on: October 27, 2018, 03:47:09 PM »
I'm fairly new and an infrequent poster, but I learn a lot from others comments on GCA. Grateful for this opportunity to reflect on a great year of golf, and everything I learned and experienced as a result. I live in Chicago, but I've been fortunate enough to play about 60 rounds on all different courses. It helps that I'm relatively healthy and not married with no kids, with a job that gives me enough vacation time.


Indian Creek
Old Marsh
PGA National
Jupiter Hills
Doral Blue
Talking Stick North
Troon CC
Estancia
Desert Forest
Black Diamond Ranch
Black Diamond Quarry
World Woods Pine Barrens
Streamsong Black
Streamsong Blue
Mountain Lake
Shoreacres
Riviera
LACC North
Sherwood
Wilshire
Lakeside
PGA West Nicklaus
PGA West Stadium
La Quinta Mountain
La Quinta Norman
Kemper Lakes
Olympia Fields North
Olympia Fields South
Olympic (Lake)
Olympic (Cliffs)
Cal Club
SFGC
MPCC Dunes
MPCC Shore
Pebble Beach
Pasatiempo
Lawsonia Links
Sand Valley
Mammoth Dunes
The Sandbox
Erin Hills
Point O'Woods
Arcadia Bluffs South
Crystal Downs
Kingsley Club
Forest Dunes
The Loop Red
The Loop Black
Oakland Hills South
Oakland Hills North
Skokie
Exmoor
Beverly
Canal Shores
Secession
Kiawah River
Yeamans Hall
Congaree
Chechessee Creek


Going to Houston and Dallas in mid-November, trying to get on Bluejack and Trinity Forest.


Hoping to tee it up with GCA'ers in 2019!





Ira Fishman

  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: Your year in golf so far
« Reply #105 on: October 27, 2018, 04:26:32 PM »
Jim,


That is a helluva list.


Any surprises on the upside?


Any disappointed expectations?


One more question: your employer need any more people?


Ira

Andy Shulman

  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: Your year in golf so far
« Reply #106 on: October 28, 2018, 08:08:45 AM »
That IS quite a list!


My year locally (DC) has been wet.  I upgraded my irons and hybrids to Ping G400s after close to 20 years with my old sticks and am VERY happy.


On the road, I took a trip out west that included visits to both Pebble Beach (you can't appreciate how small those greens are - and how much they can get in your head - until you play them) and Bandon Dunes, where I played Trails, the Preserve and the Punch Bowl for the first time (Trails, especially, is superb) and gained a much greater appreciation for Pacific Dunes following an extremely windblown round on my one previous visit.


And, on a trip to CO, I played GCA favorite, Commonground, which I found to be playable for high handicappers (I played with several) while providing a decent challenge for better players.

Jim Tang

  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: Your year in golf so far
« Reply #107 on: October 28, 2018, 09:28:50 AM »
Jim S -


What are your thoughts on Chechessee Creek?  I've never seen it but that's one place that really intrigues me.  Also, I sent you a PM.

Rich Goodale

  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: Your year in golf so far
« Reply #108 on: November 01, 2018, 10:42:28 PM »
Best new course


Tadmarton Heath: as good as any "hidden" gem in English heathland (e.g. Swinley Forest)


Best previously played course:


Tain:  haven't played there for years, but it is just as good as Brora or Golspie


Best yet unplayed new courses


True Blue and Caledonia:  my first two Strantzes a few weeks from now with my wife and good friends.  Can't wait!
Life is good.

Any afterlife is unlikely and/or dodgy.

Jean-Paul Parodi

Pete_Pittock

  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: Your year in golf so far
« Reply #109 on: November 01, 2018, 11:28:39 PM »
Started out well, then drove off the cliff. I still have my last New Zealand course showing on my handicap card. The physical problems at the Mashie led to about 45 days of recovery, then one round a couple of weeks ago, where I moved to the forward tees. Body warranty seems to have run out as I am on the sidelines again. Haven't pulled the plug at my current course in a switch to Astoria G&CC. Sutton Bay is a must play if your have the opportunity.

Thomas Dai

  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: Your year in golf so far
« Reply #110 on: November 02, 2018, 04:30:29 PM »
Best new course
Tadmarton Heath: as good as any "hidden" gem in English heathland (e.g. Swinley Forest)
Best previously played course:
Tain:  haven't played there for years, but it is just as good as Brora or Golspie


Well posted Rich.
Tadmarton and Tain slip under many folks radar but shouldn’t.
Atb

Richard Fisher

  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: Your year in golf so far
« Reply #111 on: November 02, 2018, 05:52:43 PM »
Seaside
The Old Course
Askernish *
Gullane 1
Luffness New
Goswick
Dunstanburgh
Porthcawl 
Harlech 
Aberdovey
Borth

Inland

Lindrick
Gogs Old 
Gogs Wandlebury 
Huntercombe 
Tadmarton 
Swinley Forest
Piltdown*
Royal Ashdown Forest*
Crowborough Beacon*
Copthorne*
Woking
Berkshire Red
Berkshire Blue
Fairhaven*
Newmarket Links
Northants County

Twenty-six in all, and those asterisked were new to me. Best newbie inland for me this year was probably Piltdown, followed by Royal Ashdown Forest: Askernish was my only new seaside experience in 2018, and an amazing one, although the playability issues flagged by Ran in his 147 Custodians piece are a real issue. I love all my old favourites just as much as ever, and of those that I hadn't visited in more than five years The Old Course (strange to say) and Aberdovey both stood out, as did The Berkshire Red inland. To respond to the exchanges above, Tadmarton is indeed super but not, I would respectfully submit, in the same league as Swinley or, for that matter, Huntercombe.

Most memorable golf meal was the Roast Partridge for lunch at Luffness - a gentleman's club that happens to have a golf course attached, rather than the other way round, and always a lovely, engaging place for a game.

Sean_A

  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: Your year in golf so far
« Reply #112 on: November 03, 2018, 03:28:50 AM »
I have had a roller coaster ride thus far...from awesome to surprising to ridiculous. 

First off...I played what I would call five top 50 GB&I....Elie, N Berwick, WHO, Princes & B&B.

Plus four others which help fill out the bottom 50....Crail, Little Aston, Liphook & Knole Park.

All good so far, but then a few stinkers....Meyrick Park and more especially Princes Himalayas.

A course I would play again, but not really recommend....Anstruther.

Two very surprising courses which I would recommend and definitely replay...Appleby & Alnmouth Village.

A few old stand-bys which usually serve their purpose....Oxford & Worcestershire.

And finally, a course which mildly impressed architecturally, but did more so with the WILL DO ATTITUDE of the members...Warkworth.

I don't have a great deal planned for the remainder of the year, but I will be playing some serious gems.

Ciao

I played quite a few courses since this post.

I would say several top flight courses, according to rankings: North Berwick, Pulborough, Sunny New, Porthcawl, Saunton East, St Georges Hill, Berkshire Blue.  Pulborough was very surprising in how good it is...straight into my top 10 favourites. Other than the obvious NB, none of the others made much impact on that list, though all are at least very good courses.  Porthcawl still feels very sterile to me.  I will have to give it more thought, but there is definitely something about this course which sets me the wrong way.

I also played many unranked courses, mostly long term friends: Kington, Beau Desert, Minch Old, Cleeve Cloud and Enville Highgate.  The more courses I play, the more I am convinced Beau Desert is a standout. It is slowly creeping back up my favourites list.

Epsom, Kilspindie, Luffness New and Windermere were essentially first time visits...all worth while in their own way, but none made a huge splash on favourites list. I think I prefer Epsom among these courses.   

I am not sure where West Hill lies in the big scheme of golf, but I found it better than I previously thought.  The same could be said of Saunton West.  Aberdovey....I think altering the bunkers is a mistake unless they are simply unaffordable...so disappointed.

No stinkers in the 2nd half of the year thus far.   

Of the courses I played for the first time, Pulborough is my favourite, but Appleby is right there as well.  While not a first time play this year, Westward Ho! is quite a bit better and more enjoyable than I previously thought.

Ciao
« Last Edit: November 03, 2018, 03:39:12 AM by Sean_A »
New plays planned for 2024: Nothing

Thomas Dai

  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: Your year in golf so far
« Reply #113 on: November 03, 2018, 11:44:45 AM »
I played quite a few courses since this post.
I would say several top flight courses, according to rankings: North Berwick, Pulborough, Sunny New, Porthcawl, Saunton East, St Georges Hill, Berkshire Blue.  Pulborough was very surprising in how good it is...straight into my top 10 favourites. Other than the obvious NB, none of the others made much impact on that list, though all are at least very good courses.  Porthcawl still feels very sterile to me.  I will have to give it more thought, but there is definitely something about this course which sets me the wrong way.
I also played many unranked courses, mostly long term friends: Kington, Beau Desert, Minch Old, Cleeve Cloud and Enville Highgate.  The more courses I play, the more I am convinced Beau Desert is a standout. It is slowly creeping back up my favourites list.
Epsom, Kilspindie, Luffness New and Windermere were essentially first time visits...all worth while in their own way, but none made a huge splash on favourites list. I think I prefer Epsom among these courses.   
I am not sure where West Hill lies in the big scheme of golf, but I found it better than I previously thought.  The same could be said of Saunton West.  Aberdovey....I think altering the bunkers is a mistake unless they are simply unaffordable...so disappointed.
No stinkers in the 2nd half of the year thus far.   
Of the courses I played for the first time, Pulborough is my favourite, but Appleby is right there as well.  While not a first time play this year, Westward Ho! is quite a bit better and more enjoyable than I previously thought.
Ciao


Some very nice names here. Not sure I agree with Aberdovey being disappointing although I too would prefer, maintenance affordability permitting, the more shaggy bunkering of a few years ago to now, not that now’s bunkering is bad, it’s just not as good as it was a while back. The rebuilt par-3 12th is fine.


Mention of Minch’ Old and Westward Ho! remind me that they are in many ways almost like two brothers or two sisters except one lives next to the sea and the other’s on 700 ft of elevation. Shame M’O doesn’t have a similar agreement/relationship as WHo! with the authority that owns the ground otherwise some more fences and some water might aid the greens during the main season.
Atb




Jim Lipstate

  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: Your year in golf so far
« Reply #114 on: November 03, 2018, 06:06:08 PM »
Interesting year. Started off the year learning I was no longer on my clubs grounds committee where I had earned the nickname “Chainsaw Jim”. Probably ruffled too many feathers but as the year has gone on the club has come to the conclusion that indeed we have a playability issue with the trees and something needs to be done. Now figuring out how to pay for tree removal is a big issue as yet unresolved.


Played in Palm Springs in February. Greatly enjoyed the desert and mountain views. So different from home in Louisiana.


Escaped the Louisiana heat in early September and ventured to Ireland. Played in the Southwest - Old Head, Waterville, Ballybunion, Lahinch and Doonbeg. I had a similar trip 16 years ago. Still think Lahinch is just so much fun. Those towering dunes are something else. Just love playing in Ireland. The courses, the food, the culture and people make it my favorite destination for overseas golf.


Made my second hole-in-one last week at my home club. Same hole as my first one twelve years ago. And for my upcoming 65th birthday in December I will be at Streamsong. All in all a prety good year from a golf standpoint especially if I just enjoy the enjoy the experience and not dwell on the score at the end of the day.

Sean_A

  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: Your year in golf so far
« Reply #115 on: November 03, 2018, 06:20:36 PM »
I played quite a few courses since this post.
I would say several top flight courses, according to rankings: North Berwick, Pulborough, Sunny New, Porthcawl, Saunton East, St Georges Hill, Berkshire Blue.  Pulborough was very surprising in how good it is...straight into my top 10 favourites. Other than the obvious NB, none of the others made much impact on that list, though all are at least very good courses.  Porthcawl still feels very sterile to me.  I will have to give it more thought, but there is definitely something about this course which sets me the wrong way.
I also played many unranked courses, mostly long term friends: Kington, Beau Desert, Minch Old, Cleeve Cloud and Enville Highgate.  The more courses I play, the more I am convinced Beau Desert is a standout. It is slowly creeping back up my favourites list.
Epsom, Kilspindie, Luffness New and Windermere were essentially first time visits...all worth while in their own way, but none made a huge splash on favourites list. I think I prefer Epsom among these courses.   
I am not sure where West Hill lies in the big scheme of golf, but I found it better than I previously thought.  The same could be said of Saunton West.  Aberdovey....I think altering the bunkers is a mistake unless they are simply unaffordable...so disappointed.
No stinkers in the 2nd half of the year thus far.   
Of the courses I played for the first time, Pulborough is my favourite, but Appleby is right there as well.  While not a first time play this year, Westward Ho! is quite a bit better and more enjoyable than I previously thought.
Ciao


Some very nice names here. Not sure I agree with Aberdovey being disappointing although I too would prefer, maintenance affordability permitting, the more shaggy bunkering of a few years ago to now, not that now’s bunkering is bad, it’s just not as good as it was a while back. The rebuilt par-3 12th is fine.


Mention of Minch’ Old and Westward Ho! remind me that they are in many ways almost like two brothers or two sisters except one lives next to the sea and the other’s on 700 ft of elevation. Shame M’O doesn’t have a similar agreement/relationship as WHo! with the authority that owns the ground otherwise some more fences and some water might aid the greens during the main season.
Atb





ATB


I don't mean the overall Aberdovey experience is diappointing, just the bunkering. The old bunker style was by the far the most compelling I have seen on a links and to lose that is a blow.  Aberdovey has certainly lost something by losing that unique look and the uncertainty of recovery.


Ciao
New plays planned for 2024: Nothing

Stewart Abramson

  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: Your year in golf so far
« Reply #116 on: November 03, 2018, 09:22:49 PM »
My last twelve months have included a lot of fun golf. Starting last Halloween at the event hosted at Wolf Point with Mike Nuzzo and Don Mahafey  (a day of golf I will long remember) and a round the day before at Champions (Jackrabbit) in Houston hosted by Ben Smith, it was great to meet  so many participants on this site.
Wolf Point #18 q double green with lots of movement & 2 ghosts 877 by tewiespix, on Flickr]http://

]
Wolf Point #1 w course designer Mike Nuzzo, & the Langs



In December on my annual family trip to Florida I played several courses, but the only new one was the 9 hole Winter Park course where I was paired up with former PGA tour player and well known teaching pro Wally Armstrong. Wally is a heck of a guy, known for all types of teaching gadgets . Very down to earth and funny. Our third was one of his students and he used one of his patented teaching aids on each hole. I was hitting my drives 10 yards longer by the end of the round. No joke!
Winter Park #2 par 3 146 yards 256

February was an annual business meeting in Arizona followed by several days of golf. New courses for me included Sewailo, Dove Mountain, Ventana Canyon, Quintero,  and Legacy, but my favorite was one of my regulars, Southern Dunes



Ak Chin Southern Dunes #4 a par 3

 
March was an annual guys trip to Myrtle Beach where we played mostly old favorites including True Blue, Caledonia, The Dunes , the  Barefoot courses and the Witch. It was unseasonably cold and wet and we got stuck there an an extra day because flights to the northeast were cancelled due to a blizzard.

True Blue #13 True Blue #13
 
Easter week was at the Greenbrier. Still very cold and wet, but enjoyed the Old White.
Greenbrier Old White #1 from tee 

Greenbrier Old White #11 Kathy 

In the spring I played a bunch of local courses with friends, Candlewood Valley in CT, Osiris, Garrison and West Point in NY and River Vale NJ
Garrison #1 from tee West Point in the distance

In May, I had a business trip to D.C. and played a few rounds on the drive each way: Glen Mills outside Philly, Bulle Rock outside Baltimore and Westfields outside D.C.
Bulle Rock #18 from tee

June was a great month. I spent my 65th birthday as a walking scorer at the Curtis Cup matches at Quaker Ridge. The young women played some excellent matches. I had the pleasure of meeting Lilia Vu, Lucy Li and Allison Lee whose matches I worked. Ms Vu will be a star.

The following week I did a solo golf trip from Spokane to Deer Lodge MT. I played 15 rounds in 10 days at a wide range of courses from Tom Doak’s Rock Creek Cattle Company to little 9 hole munis . It was an absolute blast in a beautiful a part of the country I’d not previously seen: Circling Raven, Rock Creek Club (Idaho), Couer d’Alene public, Galena Ridge, Shoshone, The Ranch, Rock Creek Cattle Company (MT), Old Works, Canyon River, Trestle Creek, Indian Creek, Qualchan. I played the round at Rock Creek Cattle Co, in the pouring rain with one of the assistant pros. I traveled so long to get there I couldn’t let a storm stop me. It was really a pretty miserable day.
Circling Raven #15 from tee 
Rock Creek Cattle Co #17 par 3 

August was an amazing month of golf for me.  The first week, after a business trip to Minneapolis, I took a short detour to North Dakota to play Dakota Winds which has a reversible back 9. It was  very interesting and worth a visit. It was also one of the windiest  non-oceanfront courses I’ve played. Last year was the Loop so getting in a diet of reversibles. ;)
Dakota Winds Sisseton #17
 
The following week was one of the best, after playing Glen Head Club on Long Island, I played Winged Foot East, Winged Foot West and my annual round with an old friend at Sleepy Hollow. Each year seems to bring something new to Sleepy… larger greens, fewer trees and this time new mounding, bunkers and green on the first hole.
Sleepy Hollow #16 par 3 

Winged Foot East #15  short par 4 approach

The next week was a 40th wedding anniversary trip to Cape Breton. My wife is not a golfer but encourages me to play wherever we go. I’m a lucky guy. I got hooked up with eleven guys from Vancouver who could not have been nicer. Played Cabot Links, Cabot Cliffs and Highland Links. See who joined us after the round at Cabot Links.
Cabot Cliffs #16  par 3 from tips /url]

Cabot Links #3 from tee 



Cabot Links after the round w Brandel Chamblee 


Highlands Links #3 par 3


I ended the month back in Minneapolis  and played Seth Raynor’s Mnnesota Valley which had greens and bunkers re-done last year by Bill Bergin. It is a lovely course and has a great membership (and I understand now has one of the longest waiting lists in the Twin Cities).
Minnesota Valley #2  redan


 
September included a business trip to Chicago and a short drive to Indiana to play a little Mom & Pop course called Palmira. Nothing fancy, but so much fun for $29 including rental clubs and the owner could not have been nicer.
Palmira #7 par 3
« Last Edit: November 03, 2018, 09:42:43 PM by Stewart Abramson »

Steve Salmen

  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: Your year in golf so far New
« Reply #117 on: November 05, 2018, 04:43:35 PM »
I had a good year for me getting to play some fine new courses: Plainfield CC, Diamante Dunes, Trump Aberdeen, Onwentsia, Mammoth Dunes, and probably a few others I'm not remembering.  Great courses I got to play again were Chicago, Flossmoor, Shinnecock, Sand Valley, Lawsonia, and Royal Dornoch.

I volunteered in the practice area for the US Open this year and got to see a lot of incredible players.  I think the guy to watch is Si Woo Kim, the fellow who won the 17 Players.  He works very hard.  Another cool thing was the Wednesday practice day when it was just pouring rain in the afternoon, two guys were alone on the range working hard: Ian Poulter and Tiger Woods.  Woods wasn't even wearing rain gear.  Sat and Sun the Redan was a dartboard.  They were correctly taking no chances.  There is so much tilt to that green it's hard to explain.  One practice morning, there were  15 officials on the green.  I saw one ball stop on the slope short of the green and it is quite severe.  I think the let the grass grow and softened it.

The highlight of my golf year was a four ball match, we're 1 up on the 18th, par 4.  Four lousy drives, seconds, thirds.  We all  have bogey putts. I'm first to putt, 20 ft above the hole with 80 degrees of break and I made it to end the match.
« Last Edit: November 10, 2018, 10:52:10 AM by Steve Salmen »

Michael Goldstein

  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: Your year in golf so far
« Reply #118 on: November 05, 2018, 06:55:46 PM »

Updating from my post below, I've continued to play some rustic courses around NZ and further afield.
Couple of the kiwi courses are maintained by sheep. Average green fee would be extremely low if it wasn't for Sentosa and Dornoch unaccompanied.   


Redwood Park
Dornoch
Tain
Isle of Harris
Askernish
The Old
Crail
North Berwick
Cape Kidnappers
Windross Farm
Awhitu
Great Barrier Island
Whangaparoa
Okoroire
Wairakei (9 hole)
Sentosa Serapong
Waitemata
Muriwai
Waitoria
Paparoa
Remuera





I've played a lot of super diverse golf this year.


I'm on a mission to play as many new golf courses in NZ as possible, which means a lot of very rustic golf (i.e., total annual budget of $20,000) mixed in with some interesting international courses. Absolutely loving the rustic kiwi golf which has been the catalyst for getting back into playing lots again.   
[size=78%]  [/size]
Culverden (South Island, NZ - saw one guy mowing the fairways but nobody else during my round)
Hawarden (South Island, NZ - didn't see another person the entire round)
Hanmer Springs (South Island, NZ - former home club)
South Head (Auckland, NZ - Steve Williams club)
Flinders (Mornington Peninsula, Victoria)
St Andrews Beach (Mornington Peninsula, Victoria)
Peninsula (Melbourne)
Millbrook Resort (Queenstown, NZ)
The Preserve (California)
Monterey Peninsula CC (CA)
Olympic Club (SFO)
SFGC
California Club
Pinehurst 2
Dormie Club
Tapora Golf Club (North Island, NZ - one of 5 golfers on members day)
Clark's Beach Golf Club (Auckland, NZ)
Thames Golf Club (North Island, NZ)
Hikurangi Golf Club (Northland, NZ - hidden gem)
Huapai Golf Club (Auckland, NZ)
Trinity Club (Seoul, Korea - like nothing I've seen before in terms of opulence)
Wattle Downs (Auckland, NZ)
@Pure_Golf

Daryl David

  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: Your year in golf so far
« Reply #119 on: November 05, 2018, 07:35:00 PM »

Updating from my post below, I've continued to play some rustic courses around NZ and further afield.
Couple of the kiwi courses are maintained by sheep. Average green fee would be extremely low if it wasn't for Sentosa and Dornoch unaccompanied.   


Redwood Park
Dornoch
Tain
Isle of Harris
Askernish
The Old
Crail
North Berwick
Cape Kidnappers
Windross Farm
Awhitu
Great Barrier Island
Whangaparoa
Okoroire
Wairakei (9 hole)
Sentosa Serapong
Waitemata
Muriwai
Waitoria
Paparoa
Remuera





I've played a lot of super diverse golf this year.


I'm on a mission to play as many new golf courses in NZ as possible, which means a lot of very rustic golf (i.e., total annual budget of $20,000) mixed in with some interesting international courses. Absolutely loving the rustic kiwi golf which has been the catalyst for getting back into playing lots again.   
[size=78%]  [/size]
Culverden (South Island, NZ - saw one guy mowing the fairways but nobody else during my round)
Hawarden (South Island, NZ - didn't see another person the entire round)
Hanmer Springs (South Island, NZ - former home club)
South Head (Auckland, NZ - Steve Williams club)
Flinders (Mornington Peninsula, Victoria)
St Andrews Beach (Mornington Peninsula, Victoria)
Peninsula (Melbourne)
Millbrook Resort (Queenstown, NZ)
The Preserve (California)
Monterey Peninsula CC (CA)
Olympic Club (SFO)
SFGC
California Club
Pinehurst 2
Dormie Club
Tapora Golf Club (North Island, NZ - one of 5 golfers on members day)
Clark's Beach Golf Club (Auckland, NZ)
Thames Golf Club (North Island, NZ)
Hikurangi Golf Club (Northland, NZ - hidden gem)
Huapai Golf Club (Auckland, NZ)
Trinity Club (Seoul, Korea - like nothing I've seen before in terms of opulence)
Wattle Downs (Auckland, NZ)


Michael,
Would you consider any of the “rustic NZ” courses you saw as real standouts? Any in a similar league to Arrowtown?
« Last Edit: November 05, 2018, 07:36:53 PM by Daryl David »

Michael Goldstein

  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: Your year in golf so far
« Reply #120 on: November 05, 2018, 10:07:44 PM »
Hi Daryl,


I don't consider Arrowtown that rustic - it's kept in pretty good condition and has, relatively, a lot of play.


From the courses I've seen this year I'd rate Waiotira and Tapora as really cool and recommended for the adventurous golfer. Tapora is laid out across sand dunes. Waiotira is literally a sheep paddock but has clearly been laid out by someone who understands good golf.  Amongst other rustic courses a couple of my favourites are Omakau, Hikurangi and Ahipara. 


Both these courses, in particular Waiotira and Tapora are vastly different to Arrowtown.  I'd estimate their annual budget would be no more than $20,000 and wouldn't be surprised if our group recently was the only group to play at Waiotira all week.   


@Pure_Golf

Sean_A

  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: Your year in golf so far
« Reply #121 on: November 06, 2018, 04:45:12 AM »
Michael G


What did you make of Isle of Harris?


Ciao
New plays planned for 2024: Nothing

Ronald Montesano

  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: Your year in golf so far
« Reply #122 on: November 06, 2018, 05:29:41 AM »
YIG has been quite mild this year. More spectating than playing. Highlights were Shoal Creek and a few RTJ Trail courses last spring, Green Lakes (see concurrent thread) in summer. That's about it. Timing for trips with friends has been off.


I need to take advantage of my proximity to metro Toronto for 2019 and beyond. Here's an 8-course list that would satisfy any aficionado of golf courses, old and new:


Toronto Ladies-Thompson
National Golf Links-Fazio
St. George's-Thompson
Devil's Pulpit-Hurdzan
Devil's Paintbrush-Hurdzan
Ancaster (Hamilton)-Colt
Mississauga-Thompson
Toronto-Colt


Time to get to work!
Coming in 2024
~Elmira Country Club
~Soaring Eagles
~Bonavista
~Indian Hills
~Maybe some more!!

Michael Goldstein

  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: Your year in golf so far
« Reply #123 on: November 06, 2018, 03:13:47 PM »
Michael G


What did you make of Isle of Harris?


Ciao


It is a magical wee course & one of my favourite golfing experiences in the world. I could play the first four hole loop literally over and over and over again. 
@Pure_Golf

Sean_A

  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: Your year in golf so far
« Reply #124 on: November 06, 2018, 08:09:43 PM »
Michael G

What did you make of Isle of Harris?

Ciao

It is a magical wee course & one of my favourite golfing experiences in the world. I could play the first four hole loop literally over and over and over again.


Thanks.  I am considering a trip which takes in some of the ends of the earth courses which interest me between my house and northern Scotland.  Though I suspect I won't ever have the patience for such an endeavour and will have to break it up into parts.  Anyway, IoH features highly in any such dreams. 


Ciao
New plays planned for 2024: Nothing

Tags:
Tags:

An Error Has Occurred!

Call to undefined function theme_linktree()
Back