Adrian
I fully agree with you re: the need for more speedy play on the green, particularly casual play, but.....
1. In the USA, EVERY SINGLE ROUND must be reported, stroke by stroke, for handicap purposes. There is an allowance for "gimmies" and "equitable stroke control" (aka don't count any stroke above couble bogie), but
2. In the UK, only competition rounds count for handicap purposes, but the number of "competitions" has been growing exponentially over the past 10-20 years (for various reasons, but mostly member demand, due to changes in the handicapping system 20+ years ago). While there used to be only a monthly medal, there is now a weekly medal and various bi-weekly medals and special competition medals, and now even 23 handicappers agonise over 5-footers in every game and on every green.
Bob Jones famously noted: "There is golf and there is competition golf." Far too many of us too often play competition golf rather than golf.
Od course, this is a VERY OT thread, which has absolutely nothing to do with GCA. Time for the Web Police SWAT team to get into action.....
Rich