Michael, Neil,
The old MacKenzie 7th hole was one that eroded and disappeared but the Hawtree rendition I'm sure bears more resemblance in character than the hole that replaced it (the then 8th)... MacKenzie's old 8th hole was a par-3 but it was replaced in 1935 by the par-3 3rd... This was reversed by Hawtree and that par-3 third was removed... However, by my calculations, Hawtree's par-3 8th is in a different spot to MacKenzies. My reckoning was that MacKenzie's hole played to a green site to the right of the large dune that currently flanks the right of Hawtree's 8th green site (if that makes sense)... i.e. much closer to one of the forward tees on the 9th...
Still, I have to disagree with Michael. I think Hawtree's hole to be a great addition and very spectacular... I like his work there a lot... The only thing I'm not so keen on is the new par-3 eleventh but I can certainly see why it was built... The only other negative I've heard about the renovation is that the greens are a little too undulating for their size.... I don't really agree with those sentiments though....