The only thing that matters (besides looks of course) is what fits your feet and provides the right support for the type of foot you have and whether your foot pronates or supinates etc. This and the support, sole etc will always determine what's most comfortable for you. Most of us would benefit from custom insoles to even the weight distribution out and improve our balance. Most if not all the pros have them put into their shoes. Tiger for example has them, they help your back tremendously as well as your balance and other things related.
I put them into my ski racing boots back in the 80's, huge difference. Ideally you have them in all your shoes. I don't. Golf wise, until recently, I've skipped back and forth between Nike's and Footjoy's. Nike's because I could always get them either free or close to it if truth be known. I always felt they lacked the support I needed in the front of my foot. The last ones I had last year only made it about 10 rounds and then hit the garbage can unfortunately. They created all kinds of problems. It was the top end model. Last trip to the US I ordered a couple pairs of Footjoy Icons, very comfortable and classic look, although heavy and tough to walk more than 18 a day in, created blisters at Bandon walking 36 + a day as well although I still think they are great shoes. They are spot on for formal private club golf. I tried the true linkswear shoes, didn't do it for my feet plus I can't get over how incredibly ugly they are. That just wouldn't fly in Europe. Then I tried the Ecco Biom hybrid Yak shoes, I thought they looked cool but more important when I put them on I couldn't believe how incredibly comfortable they were. Bought them on the spot and I'm wearing them all the time now. They are the most comfortable shoe I've ever had on my feet, ridiculous. However, I've taken a complete reaming at the club as everyone thinks they are the ugliest shoes they've ever seen. I'll be wearing them from now on as it's the perfect links golf shoe. If you haven't tried it, consider it. All my foot troubles created by those last Nike's are gone and my feet are super happy all the time.