Shooter,
I guess you missed my detailed review here last year on Hill's "Links at Lighthouse Sound" in Ocean City, MD. I'm not sure I "ripped" Arthur Hills, but I did make the point that the course he built really didn't fit the windy site.
But generally, I agree with JohnF that we get way too limited in discussing the work of only a very few modern day architects. I've tried to change that through some posts mentioning courses by architects like Kelly Blake Moran, Roger Rulewich, David Horn, Keith Foster, Steve Smyers, Brian Ault, Stephen Kay, RTJ Jr., etc., but for the most part, those posts have drawn limited participation.
I guess that's only natural due to the ubiquity of Tom Fazio and Rees Jones, for instance, but you're right...Arthur Hills has built courses througout the land and gets very little discussion here. I bet John Conley would argue that Hill's Dunes at Seville deserves better than a Doak Scale 5, and I'd make the same argument about his Wingpointe course in Salt Lake City. Even the aforementioned Lighthouse Sound is at least a 5. I find Hills builds some really superb holes at times, and has a neat "look" especially his green complexes, but I'm never sure that it all fits together in the way it should. For instance, I find that he puts bunkers almost in the opposite place where they should be, but I've never played a course of his that I found boring....just questionable.