Inniscrone! Inniscrone! (Attica! Attica!)
Don't let the naysayers deter you--Inniscrone is a freakin' phenomenal Redan hole. When we played it, the hole was 235 from the tips. This means a 3-wood or driver for all mortals, which also means that the ground game options critical to a Redan are more present than ever! I got to a work a beautiful draw into the green that took the slope left, banked off the back kick plate, and funneled to 15 feet. With a driver, this ground option is much more viable than with a middle, which is often the club used on today's Redans. For those who want the 180 yard short I-crone, the forward tees are there two.
Additionally, the marsh grass was cut when we were there, making this hole much less penal for the weaker player.
If this one isn't used, I'll protest loudly!
Bill, I agree that Hackensack's 12th is a very solid Redan, although the recent tree removal is a bummer (just kidding). The key there is there is a huge amount of fairway to the right to bring the kick plate into full effect. I could stand on that tee all day trying to get the draw just right.
If I had to rank the ones I've seen, I would say:
15 at NB
6 at Yeamans
8 at Inniscrone
12 at Hackensack
6 at Fox Chapel
They are all excellent, so I am separating the very best from one another.