Sorry George, obviously my opinion isn't that important since I haven't been there but it sure looks like it has 8 or 9 written all over it.
Why would you make such a comment? Have I ever said my word is final on anything? Have I ever discouraged anyone from offering an opinion that differs from mine on anything?
EVER? I have almost 9000 posts on here, find one that says anyone is wrong and I'm right.
I'll set that aside and simply remind you that I said the place is special, I just don't necessarily think the golf course architecture is special. But I remain open to the possibility that I'm wrong. By all means, if you make it out to my neck of the woods, please call or email me so I can join you and you can set me straight!
The opening post on the other thread is from John Vander Borght. Anyone who has read my posts knows that I think the world of JVB. He is a larger than life figure to me, literally and figuratively. He said PDGC is the best of the Pete Dye courses he's played. I also consider Ryan a friend and I respect his opinion. We simply differ on our view of what is great in golf.
Does everyone need to agree that Jackson Pollack is a worthwhile addition to the art scene? That he's great?
How about Monet relative to Da Vinci? Shakespeare to Conrad? Someone want to make those comparisons?
How unreal is it that Matt Ward, who disagrees agree with me over ONE aspect of Black Mesa
(it's playability for high handicappers, for those with better things to do than follow our ridiculous debate) calls out my comparison - after being asked! - to Oakmont while throwing out Pine Valley and Bethpage Black in his defense of Black Mesa?
The world is upside down.