I went to Spanish Bay fully expecting to be underwhelmed based on many things I've read and heard. I easily surpassed my very low expectations. It was a nice "value" for NCGA members, if such a thing as value exists in the Pebble Beach resort suite of golf courses. We ended up playing it 3 times, when we originally only expected to play it once. I'd take CPC, Pebble, MPCC Dunes, and MPCC Shore over Spanish 5-0 any day, but I'd probably play Spanish 3 out of 5 vs. Spyglass.
I thought it was a lot of fun to play. I thought the par 3s were all quite interesting, and we got to play some good pin placements on those holes.
A few more pictures:
The par 3 4th - a nice setting, a demanding shot, and an interesting green
The par 4 5th - looks like nowhere to hit a driver from the tee, but there's a lot of hidden room out there and some great slope to boost your tee shot if you land it in the right spot
The par 3 8th - probably my least favorite of the par 3s at Spanish, but I came about a foot away from having to pretend it was my favorite par 3 in the universe
The Par 4 11th - I think this one was called "top hat" - it had an unusual plateau in the middle of the green and the pin in this photo, while not obvious from the picture, was an extremely difficult placement.
The par 3 13th - I really liked this very short par 3 to a sliver of a green
The par 3 16th - You could really use the slope in the green to get the ball back to the right if you hit the right tee shot, which I didn't
Why am I posting photos of Spanish Bay when I just played Chambers Bay and Old Macdonald and I have almost 300 pictures of those two courses waiting to go? I am not completely sure except that I saw this thread and it was a nice trip down memory lane to go back and look at my own photos of this pleasant surprise. Again, not great but certainly enjoyable.