Shivas, where we differ is I would love the flop shot with the 4iron, but still find it stupid to putt with that club. I don't see it as watering down anything, I see it as adding a stupid shot. On the rest we are right on.
I am also thinking now that this course is maybe so wide, and the bunkers so avoidable.. that perhaps no lofted shots are ever going to be required? If that is the case, I might use hybrid... say 19 degrees?
And George, Shivas is not the one who accused others of nit-picking and side-tracking.