Jeff, I have always thought access had value. Of course the revenue means a great deal to the respective clubs as well. It has been a significant income item to all but the Open rotation courses. I actually think it is to them as well. However a trip to the UK is far more than mere golf. it is rental cars or driver, hotels/b&b's, food and other sites to see. I love the UK and will continue to visit. That does not mean I do not observe how my money is spent and what I get for it. However, even at a reduced exchange rate, I find the cost of apples and apples to be still close to 2 to 1 in value for what you get. It was 2 to 1 and pushing that to higher. This is not including London which obviously is more expensive and not a fair comparison, much like trying to use NY to analygize the US. The golf industry in the UK, particularly places like Turnberry, really pushed the limits during the boom and now has to make a major adjustment in prices IMHO.
Tiger,
As a frugal traveler who usually does b &b's or rents cottages (great value) and a professional who rarely pays green fees(but I am traveling with people who are paying), I really haven't felt the pinch in the UK/Ireland. (although I think I did pay 75 pounds at Turnberry). I also enjoy many of the lesser known courses which never seem to be that pricey say 25-50 euros/pounds. Very rarely are caddies available at most of the clubs without advance set-up so that certainly cuts costs.
Also, living in Eastern Long Island I'm used to things costing a lot. When I return to my hometown in Augusta, I always think there's an error on the check
I see the prices at The Cloister, Kiawah, Pinehurst (haven't and wouldn't stay at these places but have played the courses and I used to wait tables at The Cloister) I do feel there's good value in the UK/Ireland even when the rate was 2:1.
Being able to play Muirfield,Troon, Turnberry, or RSG without mandatory staying at a ridiculous priced resort (access) seems like a better deal than sleeping in a car at Bethpage, The Lodge at Pebble or Kiawah or Pinehurst , or joining Shinnecock.
No doubt you're right about Turnberry but there are so many other great courses/simple b &b's that I've never given it a second thought.
I honestly just don't enjoy the golf(mandatory caddies in white suits) the nonsense,and the eternity spent playing it when traveling to many of the top resorts/clubs here compared to the expense, atmosphere, and pace in UK/Ireland.
But then I live in a pretty good neighborhood
so I don't have a lot of need for domestic golf travel during the summer.