I have a question and a comment on this thread-
1. Do the "private" clubs on Britain, Ireland, Australia, Scotland,etc. have the same open door policy to local residents as they do for overseas visitors?
2. I remember after 9/11 that Pine Valley opened its doors to the public for two days for a charity event to help the firefighters. It was $1000 per person, but for a good cause and well worth it and mostly tax deductible, as well! Likewise, the Oakmont event this past fall where anyone could play for $500. for a charity event.
I think if more of the exclusionary clubs would hold such charitable events at least many non-members could have the opportunity to play and the clubs would benefit as well.
Dave,
They do.
However, they're limited by the 15 % outside revenue cap, amongst other limitations.
When you consider that the revenue cap isn't limited to GOLF, but applies to all "outside" club activities, you have to be careful in how you schedule outside events.
Remember too, that clubs get requests for their facilities years in advance.
These functions have to be scheduled, approved, budgeted, staffed, etc., etc. The process and hosting of outside events can't be viewed in a cavalier fashion.
If a miscalculation is made, and the 15 % exceeded, an audit could cause the club to lose its tax exempt status.
At a club that I'm very familiar with, they ceased approving/hosting "Sweet Sixteen" parties due to the potential for legal liability.
In addition, hosting outside events, where liquor is served, brings in another set of issues, problems and liabilities.
The overall issue is far more complex than meets the eye, and probably beyond the comprehension of those clamoring for unlimited, open access.