Robert, this is a tough question to answer at Sleepy Hollow.
The original CBM course was pretty rudimentary, just over 6100 yards with a par of 73 - four par-s and five par-5's (all holes over 440 yards were par-5's).
Four of the original holes were sold off when the course became a 27-hole layout. They were the Macdonald holes, 14 - 15 - 16 - 17 .......... now forget those hole numbers in today world because of reroutings of the course (gee, how many times)
The “inspiration” holes were few (it seems) and because of the lack of early documentation, the CBM holes, other than the par-3's, are difficult to define.
Let’s think of the par 3's and this would only apply to the original Macdonald holes - we cannot think of the other architects’s holes on the course, answering your question.
The first three architects involved were: Macdonald, one Tom Winton (quite good, who may have done the best work on the course) and then Tillinghast. Beyond that, I don’t think about.
(Remember the original clubhouse was down in the area near 1-green, 2 tee and the lower 6th tee, not the present clubhouse)
* The present 3rd on the upper course was the Macdonald Eden rendition (originally CBM’s 5th).
* The present 7th on the upper course was his Redan rendering (originally CBM’s 9th)
* The present (infamous/famous) 16th was his Short (originally CBM’s 13th)
* and the Biarritz is now the 7th on the short course (Macdonald’s original 2nd hole).
.... this is hard to follow but I can expand if you’d like in a different response, Robert.
In general, the original Macdonald holes are now:
3 holes now on the lower course (lower 6 - 7 -
11 holes on the main course
4 holes sold off (CBM 14 - 15 - 16 - 17)
* The present 15th of course the P Bowl.
* I suppose the present 4th could be a vague version of an Alps, yes, a rising fairway opening up to the green.
The present 10th is a Tillie hole over a pond, so not relative to your question., as are present holes 1 - 8 - 9 - (again) 10 - 11 - 12 - 18
.......... still with me
? (the chronology of this course gave me a migraine)
........ that leaves the par-4s (less punchbowl) and par-5's (of the original course) and I have absolutely no clue what the identity of their origin may have been.
Strange hole: During this process we found the concept for the present 5th was originally designed to play as par-5 whose green was to be where the 3rd green is now (played from the opposite direction) ............... hanging at the crest of the ravine. I guess it looked good on paper but not on the ground. The large drawing hangs in Leahy’s office.
Hope you are not as confused as I am and for the rest of the guys ...... sorry, this is pretty boring stuff.
I like this part of the story:
........ the Macdonald course design of Sleepy Hollow was nearly lost from the very beginning because of Mr. Rockefeller’s insistence that no trees were to be removed. Macdonald was furious (gee), but in the end cooler heads prevailed. “ At a meeting with Cooper Hewitt, Jim Whigham, and I had with William Rockefeller and Frank Vanderlip, I was given a free hand.” The soil was good and once the disagreement about tree removal was ironed out, construction began.
The initial summer was torrid, prompting Macdonald to remark: “This was a hard task for Raynor in appalling heat.”
(Obviously Charlie was not a hands-on guy)