Ken-
I completely agree with your questions on the PB Dye course in question. Can you imagine teaching your wife or kids to play (or to love the game of golf) on that course?
I don't have as much problem with the second PB-design in the region, but feel that the course gets away with less criticism than it deserves because of the superb maintenance, clubhouse, etc.
And I enjoyed my round at Rum Pointe, but felt it almost too "resort-oriented", i.e. could have been more challenging (or at least more consistent with his other works) around the greens.
My question is how much influence Pete (and Alice) Dye have had on PB's work over the years?