I was fortunate to play the "restored-renovated" version of Jupiter Hills last year and very much enjoyed it despite 20+mph winds.
Unquestionably, this property has the most elevation in all of South Florida. Greens and their surrounds are very well designed and are regularly maintained, I'm told, at lofty stimps. They rolled 11+ the day of my round. Add plenty of slope and the demand on a tidy short game is magnified. Fairway and approach turf was fast and firm and allowed for shots to bounce on accordingly.
The biggest negative was the preponderance of unkept sand and shrub at the edges of so many fairways. There was little or no rough and otherwise decent tee shots (especially with blustery winds) found themselves bouncing multiple times on grass before the last bounce or trickle into a depression, footprint, or shrub root 1-2ft off the fairway's edge. Pars turn into automatic bogeys or worse, making scoring frustratingly difficult. That, IMO, was a little too penal for my taste. That said, I loved the club's vibe, it's stern ask for good shots and challenging greens.
Apples to apples, it deserves its rating. It's abundant elevation, in a region with next-to-none, makes it unique and attractive. It's not in the Northeast and thus doesn't earn any knock.