Shivas, how is "long and tight" the ticket for you, but "short and tight" bad? I tend to have a harder time on tighter courses of any type, all else being equal, but shorter ones at least give you the option of playing a 4i or something off the tee for the days when the driver or 1i isn't cooperating. If I don't bring a swing to keep in play with a 4i, it really doesn't matter what the greens are like, I'm gonna suck!
We all have our days though, even though I listed Muirfield as an example of a course I wouldn't be competitive on, I shot 82 there (only one lost ball, with no caddie) despite an awful day with the putter. But I still listed it like I did because I recognize that as one of my all time best ball striking days ever. I'll be hard pressed to ever beat that unless I someday remember to bring my putter to Scotland.