How many people on GCA that have actually played Longaberger hate it? It seems like the property could have produced something better, but it's still really good as it is. I think a lot of its bad rap just comes from how expensive and hard to get on it used to be, and it gets a lot of pot shots just because Art Hills designed it. It's really quite good though.
Matt, have you played Granville? It's just down the road from Longaberger and a very good public Ross aside from an embarrassingly bad stretch of holes that were "redesigned" to make room for houses a decade or two ago. It's not great, but it has a few great moments.
I'll second the Fowler's Mill recommendation, although I played it in a downpour with Chris Sturges and we had to quit after 9 holes so I could get to a work engagement. The nine I played were very good.