Paul,
Again, I haven't played enough great courses, modern or otherwise, to judge where the River Course should be ranked. I'm not a member of a club, and usually cruise around the Chicago public courses if I'm not headed north. That said, the River Course is my favorite of the 4 up there, ranking ahead of the Straits basically because I prefer courses that use the land (or appear to) rather than being totally manufactured. That's why I find 3, 5-13 and 16 to be such great holes. I think my recent trip to Pinehurst, where I played Donald Ross courses for the first time, reinforced this view, as did last summer's trip to Banff and Jasper. To me, the weaknesses of the River course (such as they are) are in the more obviously "manufactured" elements - the mounding between 1 and 2, 4, although a great green, seemingly out of place, as is 14 (again a fun hole, though). I much prefer it to PGA West, La Quinta Mountain, Sawgrass and the other Dye courses (with a few similar holes) that sit on less-good land. Agree/disagree?
Jeff Goldman