Thanks Dan, this thread is like a GCA ice core to a simpler time...
I had a few ideas...the two courses on Lanai in Hawaii are a mandatory ferry or puddle-jump from the usual hawaiian tourist spots, and even Princeville is over an hour over narrow roads from the resorts on Kauai.
The Askernish project looks like it will be at the end of the earth, and I felt the same way driving to Connemara over one-lane roads (and then being told I was the closest to the US in all of Europe).
Here in MA, Kittansett is at the end of a peninsula, way out into Buzzard's Bay, but it's still only 90 minutes from the Hub.
I have to get up to Cape Breton sometime, but I think it will be Air Canada to Halifax, then Sydney. The drive sounds great, but I can't wait that long to play.
My last nominee is Va-Jo-Wa Golf Club in Island Falls, ME, 370 miles from Boston, 90 miles north of Bangor, 40 mins from New Brunswick on I-95. It's slightly akin to pasture golf, although truly a formal golf course, but my family's new vacation house is right across the lake. The course may merit its own thread one day (i had a great description of it erased once), as its combined challenges, questionable fairness, questionable maintenance, but very "down Maine" character make it one of my favorite hidden gems.
-Brad