Pine Hills CC in Sheboygan, WI. To me it’s a top 3 course in golf rich state. If we’re using magazine rankings as the standard for what’s over-rated, then this is hands down a grossly under-rated course.
Also - I appreciate all the love for my home club (Blue Mound), which is also under-rated, although it’s hard to say anything by Raynor is under rated these days, but again if we’re using the magazine rankings then it qualifies.