I agree that it’s probably still the best list. As you say, it’s the most longstanding but really it is a completely different beast to what it was in the beginning:
It used to have a panel of about 80 industry folks, architects, administrators, ex-pros. Then it was completely shaken up to Chris Bertram as editor (and final decision maker) plus a panel of 20 advisers, all amateur enthusiasts with none from the industry (David J can correct me if that has changed).
I think you can probably argue the same thing with all lists: Once upon a time they were biased towards “championship” venues that had held tournaments and more suited the “good” player. In recent years they’ve over-corrected to quirk, obvious features / touch-points, ease of play and “fun”. Challenge has become a dirty word.
The correct place is somewhere in the middle. Whilst this list is moving more to the latter position, it still feels the most genuine and closest to the way I think. Still a few head-scratchers but there always will be.