I guess it just depends upon one's definition of "great shape"
seeing twice as many cart tracks all over a golf course is at best a bad aesthetic, at worst more compaction(won't always show as a problem in a few months)
But as always JK(and you) COULD be right.
With Covid limiting bag carrying in NY, while other area clubs opted to have 4 carts and 2 caddies(generally with caddies riding on the back) or 2 carts carrying the bags while the players walked...
We opted for caddies pushing one cart and pulling another, and many players chose to carry or push/pull themselves-all carrying their own rake.
Caddies did better than ever $$wise as many(about half) groups only took one caddie, and the historically poorer paying players opted not to take a caddie. The additional rounds played and a few caddies who did not return due to Covid made it all work out nicely without mandatory caddies-a practice I have long wanted to get rid of. Who knew Covid would accelerate such a practice?
Caddies make more $, members who don't want caddies don't have to take one, and slightly less personnel to manage.
The reality is nearly all did take caddies, but why force them on a player(the ONLY mandatory caddie rule is that if taking a cart, they do have to take a caddie-to avoid trying to substitute one for the other)
win-win-win
As always, we allowed carts only for medical or over age 65 -and we did use single rider carts for those who took them.
Surprisingly, play was faster than ever, and cart use declined.
I think quite a few caddie dependent members learned a bit about self reliance during the period caddies weren't allowed-that and less one-on-one caddy conversations kept things moving.