I've recently seen some threads going around on the best par 3s and par 5s, which got me thinking about par 4s. In your opinion, who builds the best par 4s and why? Please cite specific examples if possible
For sake of argument, its best to stick with architects who have designed/built multiple courses so we have multiple data points to go from. No doubt a course like Pine Valley and Oakmont exist out there with outstanding par 4s, but these are one-off/one-of-a-kind type deals. So of those architects who have been more promiscuous and "got-around" which one would you say builds/built the best par 4s?
I'll start off with my two cents...and I fully understand my background and exposure is nowhere near as extensive as many on this site. I know I'll certainly be called a butt-boy, but screw it cause I don't really care as I think he does amazing stuff in my book.....so I gotta go with our own Tom D.
My data points would be holes:
#2, 6, and 7 at Pacific Dunes
#7, 12, and 13 at Ballyneal
#5, 11 and 14-16 at Rock Creek.
All fantastic and world class holes in my book. And this is not to say these are the only terrific holes at these courses, but the ones that stand out the most to me.
#1b would Dr. MacK. Between what he's done at Pasatiempo and Cypress Point alone, put him way up there...just sheer brilliance in his work at those courses. And then seeing his other work on TV like Royal Melbourne, ANGC amongst others...