The Dismal River reference on the original topic listing was just a cheap trick to try to get more views/comments. Sorry for any disappointment.
Hole 16 Par 5, 482/518
This hole was altered back in the 1980s. The tee shot is original, but the green was moved so an approach would not have to play across an increasingly busy road. There is OOB all along the right side, but the hole doglegs left and too much conservatism from the tee can result in tree trouble on the second shot.
A large swale cuts across the fairway about 250 yards from the tee. Getting to the other side of it requires a drive of about 300 yards and a climb.
Along with a turn left, the approach also runs downhill to a green tucked in the trees. I did not take any photos of the green, but the contouring and bunkering are not really in character with the rest of the course.
The original green for this hole has been maintained as a practice area.
Hole 17 Par 4, 338/361
Ignore the hideous tree in the right rough just past where the fairway begins. That has been removed since I was there. It’s hard to believe that anyone thought such a planting improved the hole, as the tee shot is plenty interesting without it. A tee shot of about 240 yards gets you started down the hill, but I’m not sure what would be gained by that.
Sorry for the out of focus picture of the approach.
The green is in sort of a punchbowl setting.
Hole 18 Par 3, 143/149
Nothing wrong with ending a course with a par 3, but this one is a bit of a letdown given the quality of the holes that precede it. It’s not a bad hole, but like the 16th green just a bit of a misfit. I’ve read somewhere that as far back as the 1920s, Ross proposed putting a par 3 elsewhere on the course and ending on the 17th. With the road situation, it seems tough to find a way to do this today.
Tour is finally complete – something in advance of the one year anniversary of my visit. I really appreciate Ian Andrew’s encouragement to see the course – it’s well worth a trip. I hope to make it back there in a year or two and see the improvements that he has made.