Wow! That thread title is really specific!
Yes, it is, but the combination of questionable architecture in Florida and great architecture I experienced yesterday got me thinking about this issue. For me, a split fairway hole is a positive signal for me on several levels. It shows:
1) The architect is trying to do something unconventional.
2) The architect is not dumbing down the course for public consumption.
3) The hole has multiple options.
4) The hole most likely has width.
5) The golfer is forced to show the world (or his playing partners, whichever inspires you more) what he or she is made of.
In addition, a split fairway on a public track always piques my interest in that course. When I ask, "what did you think of Dogtrack National?" and somebody says, "well, Fart Hills isn't my favorite architect, but... ...there is a neat split fairway par four on number 7..." I'm immediately more interested in the place.
So...what are your favorite split-fairway holes on public courses?
I'll start things off strong:
4, 14 and 15 at World Woods Pine Barrens
5, 10, and 15 at Morgan Hill
3, 8 and 11 at Lederach
5 and 14 at Mill Creek
7 at Byrncliff
17 at Seven Oaks
16 at Inniscrone
16 at Links at Hiawatha
11 at Streamsong (Red)
15 at Canterbury Woods
10 at Kettle Brook
Thoughts?