You have learned well. The best way to have a perfect course is to reduce the desire of the members to play.
Desire? Could you expand on your answer?
One of the reasons fans work so well is that they create an environment where members would rather do something else. Same with cart path only. What I found most curious about your post was that you had more rounds with dead greens then with perfect ones. How can that be attributed to anything but the desire of your members to play?
[/quote]
We have actually have more rounds this summer than last year. I did not say the course was closed. We have simply moved agronomy up to #1 on our priority list when it comes to setting our schedule. Our membership actually enjoys having the course available all the time and free of organized events.
You are correct in that a roaring fan does not enhance anyone’s enjoyment of the game (although they are nice to stand in front of on a humid, 100 degree day). They have become the norm, at least for clubs in Charlotte who care about their course conditions and are serious about helping their superintendent. Charlotte CC, Carmel CC and Myers Park CC have all installed fans on their greens. We only have 8 while some of the others have all 18 holes plus every practice green “insured” by a fan. The alternative, of course, is to cut the greens at ¼ inch from June to August… something our board decided was not the right direction.
We used to have a mid-June member guest, a few outside events (amateur) and several other large functions scheduled in the summer. By moving these to the cooler months we might have found the right solution. April, May and October are crazy, but the stress on the course has been seriously reduced.
I have the utmost respect and understanding for any architect’s negative opinion of fans. A ten foot metal monstrosity takes away from the natural beauty of any greens complex. However I give top priority to the following when offering my opinion to the Board on any subject regarding the course:
“GOLF COURSES ARE MEANT TO BE PLAYED… NOT PHOTOGRAPHED.”
When we weigh the alternatives regarding fan installation… “playing the game” trumped “ taking a picture.” It’s that simple. Anyone who considers themselves a “golf club” should do the same.