a strong vote for Olde Kinderhook....and I have played most of those mentioned.....
the course itself presents wonderfully diverse strategy choices,
and a wide variety of hole shapes and lengths and hazards...
and, his "mounding phase/tendency" is kept to a minimum (kind of) ...
as a Club, diplomatically speaking, it has not reached it's potential...
remember, Matt Ward and the Redanman can't both be wrong!!