Tom,
When I said you already gave away #2, I literally meant it. You said Adam Clayman is a member at Pinon Hills (my clue was correct). The answer is Pinon Hills.
Once called (and still considered) one of the best bargains in the country. It opened up at $11 in 1989 and maxes out on weekends at $25 now. Located in the remote location of Farmington, NM.
For MV,
The 18th is above the @, yes. Famous 12th over water is far left, upper corner.
Par 4 14th has the famous sweeping green where a Tour player hit the far left, ball rolled to top of hill, then back down to front right and in the hole.
Narrow, reachable par 5 15th follows.
539 yard, par 5 5th is far right (dogleg right), where Tiger hits 2-iron, 2-iron to reach in two.
Here's the GCA write-up:
http://www.golfclubatlas.com/muirfieldvillage1.html