Has anyone played a "Cliffs" course that they've liked?
Mike, actually, I have. I was fortunate to spend 4 days down there last month and had a wonderful time. We played Wright's course, Nicklaus' at Walnut Cove, Fazio's on Lake Keowee and Jackson's Glassy course.
Wright's course certainly has the least 'wow' factor, but it is pretty solid. You wouldn't make a special effort to get here but you would be glad you played it if in town. Definitely not mountain golf.
The Nicklaus and Fazio courses are both enjoyable and well-maintained. They both had a number of good holes, and a few that left you suspecting that more could have been done. As Turboe said, the Fazio at Keowee is lakeside and in no way a mountain course. The Nicklaus didn't feel like a full-blown mountain course either, though it certainly has the views and more of the up-and-down you'd expect at that elevation.
With respect to Turboe, I disagree with him regarding Jackson's Glassy. I had expected it to be my least favorite, but after three rounds I found myself enjoying it more and more. It did not match the image MikeC posited.
Sure, there are a couple of holes that make you shake your head--not sure that could have been avoided with that parcel. Having said that, I like the 7th at Pocono Manor (for MikeC), and don't have much issue with those holes that make you shake your head or wonder. The views are other-worldly in many places (and yes, I add mental points for that..it adds to the experience for me), and the greens added much more interest than any of the other Cliff's courses I saw---many holes had places where there was a big price to pay for being out of position, and a 2 (or 3) putt was far from a given from relatively short distances.
I am curious how the new Player course will turn out.