Yesterday I played Merion West, Merion East and Aronimink. It was a 54 hole extravaganza, which ended with a fine dinner while we watched a rare Phillies come from behind victory over the more talented Mets. A few comments ...
We started out at Merion West. Man, was this fun. While the 3rd is a reachable par 5, I love how it narrows at the finish just asking you to brave the out of bounds. I wasn't so bold. You could make a case for the 5th hole being one of the best of both courses. Six, seven and eight just have to be experienced to appreciate how "short" doens't mean unchallenging. On the back, 14 and 15 are two personal favorites. Also, one cannot help but be impressed with the routing on this smaller track of land.
We then played the East. I know this course is often discussed at lenght on these boards (and with good reason). What many might (and I stress might) not be aware of is how this course is in condition for championship play at all times. There is simply not a mundane shot out there. One is required to think long and hard before striking your ball. If you don't, many a scoring opportunity will be lost. I played resonably well, capped by a par long 2 putt par on 18.
Aronimink is in impeccable condition. Fast and firm to be sure. Brute length with green complexes that are exceptional, IMO.