Rich, As you know I have only played Skibo once and it was in the best of company. Allen Grant is the host of all hosts and a friend to cherish. I really found most of the front, 3 to 7, to be the weakness in the course. It is hard to really take the last few holes too seriously either but they are beautiful and fun. I just felt the weak front nine holes, inconsistant grasses, distance between a few holes on the front and the holiday course finish kept the course from being taken as much more than a nice part of the Skibo experience. I am not sure much of that was addressed in your notes on the renovation. I for one, loved the old club house. I can only imagine how nice it is now. Skibo is something we all should experience, but I would never miss a round at Dornoch to play there.