Chris,
Perhaps you’re right. I didn’t think what I wrote was an attack as much as I thought it was a polite way of saying that 1) you’re not going to get the answer you want and 2) no one here is under an obligation to provide club data to you. I’m sure you understand that when clubs give proprietary information to their members, discretion is to be expected.
Back to your latest. If we’re going to engage in the fun of identifying poster’s logical fallacies, I’d just ask that you weren’t so forceful about shifting the burden of proof to others here that have tried to provide you information. Claiming that staff is driving the bus or round-about insinuating that another poster’s words are vague and so you need more proof is just not productive. People have reasoned with you and because you don’t like the answer, you browbeat. I’m not sure what else to say except that if it matters this much, they will gladly accept your membership application without delay at Brora. They’re great people, it’s a lovely village, and the golf course is pretty good with other courses of interest nearby. But before you jump in though, ask yourself if it’s the sheep or the golf course that attracts and retains members at Brora.