I can't recall exact scores but would wager that my cumulative score on the tenth was at least a couple strokes higher than the second, even though the latter is supposedly the scarier hole. I think it's because once you get to a spot in front of the second green (tee shot, second shot, third shot, "other") you have an easier job facing you from there than at any place around the tenth green.
When Mike and I played #2 the first time I landed a pitching wedge (or 9-iron maybe) a good 15+ yards short of the green and was thinking I had hit the perfect shot. It was so hard downwind that the ball ended up not only over the green but in the weeds waaay over the green. But later in the week the wind was less and I still never made a bogey or better. What a hole! But the tenth is tougher IMO.
P.S. I think if I had one more shot at Foxy and the wind wasn't blowing too hard I could at least have a reasonable putt at par. I played it better each time around but still not good enough.