This afternoon, after playing the first nine holes of his project at Madison Lakes, Mike Young extended his generosity to my father and myself, and we played the beautiful Athens Country Club. We played the original 18, the East and South nines, designed by Donald Ross in 1926.
This course has made it into my top ten, and is my second favorite Ross course, to Hartford (CT) Golf Club. As is the case on most Ross courses, the real work is to be done around the greens. My favorite green complexes were at the 5th and 11th.
Number 5 is an uphill par 3 of about 170 yards, with a green wide open in front, with flanking bunkers. Illusion is the key to the supremacy of this green. The green looks like just a medium-tilt back-to-front green, but as one approaches, one sees a green with a splendid little shelf in back, and a false front. Today, the pin was in the front middle, and I found myself with a tough chip shot from just beyond pin-high, right of the green. Nothing spectacularly memorable, but just solid, thought-provoking stuff.
#11 features a narrow, angled green elevated well above the landing area. Just right and short of the green is a fair-sized hill which can be used to kick the ball onto the green, avoiding two bunkers short and to the left. However, just long lies an interesting flat chipping area which presents the option of putting or a delicate downhill chip shot. I've always liked chipping areas which present equally viable options, and this hole epitomizes that.
The other thing that I really liked about ACC was the collection of half-par holes. Numbers (counting the East/South as an 18-hole course) 1, 3, 6, 10, 11, and 12 are all holes that make ACC a great match play golf course. 6 and 10 are both downhill par fives of under 460 yards and possess two of the most severe greens on the course. When one looks at the scorecard, one thinks birdie on these two holes, but after walking off with par or worse, one respects the holes far more.
There's my review; sorry if it's a bit tedious and obfuscatory.