Thanks everyone for the helpful comments.
Tom O': I think we fit in pretty well on the dues and initiation fees in our market, and are right on with the cart and tee times, too. Reciprocal agreements are something worth looking into, for us. As a semi-private, that will be an interesting discussion. You are in a market with a much higher base than ours, but it sounds like you have made a conscious effort to fit in within that structure. Entering year 130 you must be doing a lot right!
Mike: That's a great point about not foisting a new marketing concept onto the club, and listening to the core that is there. I certainly hope that I don't make that mistake, after-all, I'm the newbie, and enthusiasm without buy-in is a net negative.
Don: I really need to get my clubs to Canada! Yours is a good point about making the basics work and let the rest take care of itself. That's one I'll need to remind myself of....
Ken: Sounds like an interesting setup. Agreed that "too many" isn't the challenge we face, either. I was told our total footprint is about 35 acres, which is small, but also means that sitting in the clubhouse the entire course is there in front of you, and it's quite lovely. We do have some interesting 2nd tees, but in playing armchair architect, not sure there are many additional tee sites that wouldn't bring other tees and greens (more) into play. Making those kind of changes are beyond what we are talking about now, though. We do have some outings, and as a semi-private, we also close to the course for just the members at times, like for the member-guest, on weekends no less. With no tee times, the double tee time problem isn't quite the problem, but you make a good point that the second nine at a lower rate comes out of the till. You can't fight the math: 9 hole courses just don't have the same inventory of 18 hole rounds as the 18 holers.
Carson: sounds like you fell into a great situation. I don't see us joining forces with an 18-hole course, but I guess that is something to consider. I think many of our members fall in love with our course, too, probably for many of the same reasons you have. We do a great job of manicuring the course, though it's not Augusta, certainly. The rough isn't too high, the fairways hold the ball up, and the greens run true.
Mark: Practice facilities do add a lot to any membership, as we all sometimes just want to work on our game. We have four sets of tees, mens and womens, front and back 9. That seems to work for now. And a 4 handicap is about what the club champion plays. Me, I'm closer to the 40 :-)
Thanks everyone, lots of good stuff.