Phil Young- Great point about how much discussion the various holes on the Black can merit in a "which hole is the best" type argument. Apart from the merits of the holes as a whole, you can generate a great deal of discussion on the merits of individual shots. For example, I think the drive at #12 is the most demanding on the course given the bunker off the tee. The most demanding approach is a close call between #5 and #15. I too have a great affinity for #15. That uphill approach over the bunker complex is one of the great shots in golf. Also, the green on #15 is one of the more interesting ones on the Black.