Jeff,
I'm sure there are others that could give you a better update than I, but here's my take based on a couple plays. To my knowledge of the three current nines, the Creek is from the original course (Killian/Nugent), the Lake is a mixture of old/new, and the Marsh is all new. I think a few of the original holes were bulldozed when it was re-done.
Every comment I've heard period about the course is that it was better before the re-design, and some really dislike the course now because of how much better it was originally. I never played the original, so I can't say.
I will say the Creek to me is by far the most fun nine to play. It has the ambiance you remember. The original holes on the Lake have some of that as well. The new holes on the Lake I don't care for at all. There is one weird par five with a partially double fairway and another odd dog-leg par four. The Marsh is what it is, the holes are nice enough but completely surrounded by houses. The houses dominate all of the new holes and the ambiance is gone.
I still think its a good course, but the Creek is far superior to the other nines in my opinion.
Mike,
Limberlost is a quaint old par 70 course that maybe measures 5500 yards. It was probably built at two times but two different people. The one half of the property is fairly featureless save for a large ridge that runs through it. Otherwise the whole thing is mowed at one height save for tees and greens...no telling where one fairway ends and the other begins. Biggest difference on the other side is that there are a few more undulations and trees.
It might be a fun course to play if there weren't others out there. Otherwise its exceptionally dangerous, as I mentioned in another thread a ball flew about 3 inches past my ear on the fly.
Rather scary. Doesn't attract a highly skilled group of golfers by any means.