The End Of An Era At Brora?

[Simon Barrington]

I question the notion that the greens staff are/were the ones driving the change to remove the livestock from the course. It would not surprise me at all if a sizable number of club members have been wanting to do this for many years.

Agreed
(Only time will tell if they were correct)

[Chris Hughes]

I question the notion that the greens staff are/were the ones driving the change to remove the livestock from the course.

Specifically, what have you heard/seen that makes you think this?

[James Boon]

Chris,


In the papers the club put together around this issue ahead of the vote, they mention / remind that in the early 2000s there was a similar vote and the members wanted to remove the livestock then, but for various reasons it was never followed through. I'm not a regular enough visitor to the club to know exactly what the membership feel, but if they wanted to remove the livestock 20 odd years ago, it would surprise me if this recent development was just driven by the greenstaff.


Cheers,


James
 

[Chris Hughes]

Chris,


In the papers the club put together around this issue ahead of the vote, they mention / remind that in the early 2000s there was a similar vote and the members wanted to remove the livestock then, but for various reasons it was never followed through. I'm not a regular enough visitor to the club to know exactly what the membership feel, but if they wanted to remove the livestock 20 odd years ago, it would surprise me if this recent development was just driven by the greenstaff.


Cheers,


James

Interesting, thanks.


Sounds kinda vague, where can we read about that?

[Ben Sims]

Chris,


In the papers the club put together around this issue ahead of the vote, they mention / remind that in the early 2000s there was a similar vote and the members wanted to remove the livestock then, but for various reasons it was never followed through. I'm not a regular enough visitor to the club to know exactly what the membership feel, but if they wanted to remove the livestock 20 odd years ago, it would surprise me if this recent development was just driven by the greenstaff.


Cheers,


James

Interesting, thanks.


Sounds kinda vague, where can we read about that?

The club sent out a detailed information packet to members for both issues presented in the EGM.

[Chris Hughes]

Chris,


In the papers the club put together around this issue ahead of the vote, they mention / remind that in the early 2000s there was a similar vote and the members wanted to remove the livestock then, but for various reasons it was never followed through. I'm not a regular enough visitor to the club to know exactly what the membership feel, but if they wanted to remove the livestock 20 odd years ago, it would surprise me if this recent development was just driven by the greenstaff.


Cheers,


James

Interesting, thanks.


Sounds kinda vague, where can we read about that?

The club sent out a detailed information packet to members for both issues presented in the EGM.

Excellent.


Was there a vote in the "early 2000's" as mentioned above? 


How much will the contractual/legal costs be for executing on the recent ill-advised successful vote?

[Ben Sims]

Chris,


I think it was mentioned in the info packet but I can’t be sure. I’m too busy experimenting with Yorkshire puddings to look it up.


You seem very struck by this decision. I hope your holiday season can make up for the pain you seem to be feeling over Brora’s membership deciding what they think is best for Brora. Merry Christmas.

[Chris Hughes]

Chris,


I think it was mentioned in the info packet but I can’t be sure. I’m too busy experimenting with Yorkshire puddings to look it up.


You seem very struck by this decision. I hope your holiday season can make up for the pain you seem to be feeling over Brora’s membership deciding what they think is best for Brora. Merry Christmas.

@BenMalach, does this constitute an "Ad hominem attack"?!?