Bret, the story behind the club considering the move is tragic, interesting and humorous. In 1926, the clubhouse burnt to the ground. This made the club consider moving. Per Wolfert Roost's club history book published in 2015, "The Albany Evening News on January 28, 1927, two members of the Board, William A. Humphrey and Winslow M. Mead, were tasked with making arrangements to "secure an option on which to build a new clubhouse and golf course."
The article stated, "One day last week it was suggested to them that a certain farm on the outskirts had admirable natural advantages. Donning mufflers, mittens and rubber boots, they set out to procure an option on the place." After examining the site they came to an agreement with the owner, “whereby an option was offered on payment of $50.”
They were quite pleased with themselves until they reported back to “the committee that they had been successful in their mission” where upon they were “met by jokes and laughter.” They had gone to the wrong farm…
Maybe it was the good laugh at themselves or some other reason, but a short time after this the Club decided to remain and build a new, modern clubhouse using the foundations of the mansion [the mansion was the home named “Wolferts Roost” and so reason the club used that for its name].In that sense the true Roost will always be the foundation of the Club.”
Once again, per the club history book, “1931 found the Club in a fortunate situation. Its financial condition now relatively stable, so much so that when a good opportunity presented itself that they were to take advantage of it. An ability to purchase a tract of 41.5 acres adjacent to the Club’s property at a very low price came its way. It was so inexpensive that purchasing it allowed them to solve what some members viewed as a probllem with the Tillinghast course.
“Although it was considered challenging even for good players, it was felt that the course was not as good as it could be due to the limited acreage on which it was routed. This new property would enable the Club to design a new course that would meet the increasing challenges being presented by advancements in equipment technology such as better golf balls and steel shafts which were quickly replacing the hickories of old.
“And so, that spring the the Club hisred leonard Rainer of Cooperstown to design the new course. Today Rainer is only remembered for this single golf course design. He may have been a professiona in that region who had done some design work locally, but nothing else is known about him now. But his legacy is till enjoyed at the Roost today.
“In creating the redesigned course and incorporating it into the new property, most of what Tillinghast designed was lost as the course was re-routed and every hole substantially changed or relocated entirely. Rainer was assisted in laying out the new course by Louis Godfrey, the course Superintendent. John Epsey, who began working at WR in 1928 and would serve as Superintendent later on durin his 50 years at the Roost, supervised the construction of the course.”