Isn't it hard to decipher how a great course is on one play? Especially when you are focused on your game? Just walking the course I can see it but I'm always trying to score and I'm sure I miss more than half of what I should be appreciating....
I too have and extremely hard time fully appreciating a course the first
few times I play it. First impressions seem to be a combination of conditioning (often lipstick on a pig) and how bad the course kicked my ass (often because I lost the plot). Still, I think my biggest issue is that it's easy for me to see the problems with the course, but it's much harder for me to sus out the virtues.
Like the second time through of a novel or film, you see the foreshadowing and themes more clearly. Playing with a local/member/caddie has really helped me understand courses sooner.
E.g.
#14 at Lincoln Park GC: I thought it was entirely badly designed until I saw a member play the hole in entirely backwards: mid-iron off the tee, playing
away from the green and lengthening the hole... completely counter-intuitive until you see it done. My respect for the much derided "Stinkin' Lincoln" has grown significantly because the strategies on many holes are so subtle, it took me a dozen playthroughs to see them. It's not a good course, but it has a few architectural gems.
When I think of the ideal/template holes from
my life, many are based on the quirks I find on a course I initially don't like.