I'm bumping this thread, having played Valley CC in a GAP qualifier yesterday. I've driven I-81 more times than I care to remember, and always wondered about that course way below the highway, just south of the I-80 interchange. My regret is not visiting sooner than yesterday.
The greens were still rounding into shape for the season but I can't imagine them rolling too much faster without losing some possibilities for locating holes. I'm not sure why Jim Nagle in an earlier post said he'd want a "do-over" on #4 green -- it was one of my favorites with many interesting and potentially diabolical areas to place the pins. Unfortunately didn't have the chance to put a couple of tees in the greens and putt to some of those spots.
It's a well preserved Tillinghast and for me it was well worth the drive.
Fun fact: the baseball manager Joe Maddon's house is behind the 8th green. He grew up in the area and hosts an annual golf outing entitled the "Try Not to Suck in The Valley Golf Classic."