News:

Welcome to the Golf Club Atlas Discussion Group!

Each user is approved by the Golf Club Atlas editorial staff. For any new inquiries, please contact us.


Philippe Binette

  • Karma: +0/-0
Who governs interventions on the Old course ?
« on: February 06, 2022, 08:52:58 PM »
More a political question here... correct my statement if I'm wrong


I think the Links Trust runs The Old Course at St Andrews, right ?


The R&A runs the Open and modify the course for "their" championship... but they don't own the course


I think there are 5-6 other clubs that have some "rights" on the course.


Let's say the R&A want to do some stupid changes to the Old Course for the Open.. (ex: change the bump in front of the 4th green for a big bunker)


Could the 5-6 other clubs unite together against the R&A and overturned the proposed changes ?
Or
How does it work ?


Joe_Tucholski

  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: Who governs interventions on the Old course ?
« Reply #1 on: February 06, 2022, 09:23:54 PM »
I have no inside information so maybe there are others who will chime in, but it looks like the Links Trust and their management committee are the ones who oversee the course maintenance and therefore changes.  It looks like the Scottish government, the Fife Council and the R&A appoint the committee.  I'm guessing the R&A has a large amount of influence on course changes.
Who We Are - St Andrews Links : The Home of Golf


I don't think the local clubs have any say on the course.  Additionally, membership in the club doesn't guarantee a links ticket and unlimited play on the courses.  Some members pay as they go.  I think the only preferential treatment is comps and the ability to purchase a special ticket for competitions (only if on the waitlist for the regular ticket).

Richard Fisher

  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: Who governs interventions on the Old course ?
« Reply #2 on: February 07, 2022, 08:20:55 AM »
Whole books have been written on this general subject.


The links have always been public and  until 1946 some local St Andrews townspeople got their golf 'on the rates' for nothing extra...seriously. Joe's general comments seem correct to me, and the Links Trust website makes the situation pretty clear: the 'R and A' course at St Andrews is arguably the New Course, just as much as the Old Course, and it is not coincidental that the principal foursomes match-play competition of the R&A club itself, the Calcutta Cup, is held during the Autumn Meeting over the New Course.


The St Andrews Club (whose clubhouse abuts the 18th fairway) was founded in 1843 and was historically the 'artisan' club, with the Thistle Club (founded in 1817) a social notch higher, and the New Club (founded in 1902 with premises on Gibson Place) the club for local mercantile and professional persons. There is also the St Regulus Ladies Golf Club (founded 1913) and the St Rule Club ( a ladies' social club which became a golf club, founded in 1897).


It's important to stress that in Scotland historically the St Andrews situation was far from unique, with e.g. Carnoustie and Montrose and Musselburgh likewise having a number of different clubs serving different sectors of society playing over the same course or courses (including, at Musselburgh, the Honorable Company before they moved to Muirfield). Some of these institutions still survive, although there has been a certain amount of rationalisation over the past half-century.


I'm sure some Scotland-based GCA friends will know a great deal more!

Adam Lawrence

  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: Who governs interventions on the Old course ?
« Reply #3 on: February 07, 2022, 08:53:01 AM »
Whole books have been written on this general subject.


The links have always been public and  until 1946 some local St Andrews townspeople got their golf 'on the rates' for nothing extra...seriously. Joe's general comments seem correct to me, and the Links Trust website makes the situation pretty clear: the 'R and A' course at St Andrews is arguably the New Course, just as much as the Old Course, and it is not coincidental that the principal foursomes match-play competition of the R&A club itself, the Calcutta Cup, is held during the Autumn Meeting over the New Course.


The St Andrews Club (whose clubhouse abuts the 18th fairway) was founded in 1843 and was historically the 'artisan' club, with the Thistle Club (founded in 1817) a social notch higher, and the New Club (founded in 1902 with premises on Gibson Place) the club for local mercantile and professional persons. There is also the St Regulus Ladies Golf Club (founded 1913) and the St Rule Club ( a ladies' social club which became a golf club, founded in 1897).


It's important to stress that in Scotland historically the St Andrews situation was far from unique, with e.g. Carnoustie and Montrose and Musselburgh likewise having a number of different clubs serving different sectors of society playing over the same course or courses (including, at Musselburgh, the Honorable Company before they moved to Muirfield). Some of these institutions still survive, although there has been a certain amount of rationalisation over the past half-century.


I'm sure some Scotland-based GCA friends will know a great deal more!


The Old course was completely free to play until 1912 or so. The imposition of the first charge was extremely controversial, and was pushed through at the same time as it was decided to build the Eden course.
Adam Lawrence

Editor, Golf Course Architecture
www.golfcoursearchitecture.net

Principal, Oxford Golf Consulting
www.oxfordgolfconsulting.com

Author, 'More Enduring Than Brass: a biography of Harry Colt' (forthcoming).

Short words are best, and the old words, when short, are the best of all.

Tom_Doak

  • Karma: +3/-1
Re: Who governs interventions on the Old course ?
« Reply #4 on: February 07, 2022, 09:37:25 AM »
Philippe:


Politics are a difficult thing to put in writing, but we saw from the changes to The Old Course a few years ago, that the Links Trust went along with what the R & A wanted, without pushback.  Indeed, both bodies kept the proposed works a secret until just a couple of weeks before the bulldozers came out -- neither the general membership of the R & A nor the local clubs had heard anything about it until it was announced.


The Links Trust is supposed to preserve the golf courses for the town and for the world, but it has morphed into the organization that decides how The Old Course will be monetized.  Hosting The Open regularly is key to that, so, generally, they are going to go along with almost anything the R & A says is important to keeping the course relevant for championship play.


Your hypothetical is a little more complicated, because it would be hard to argue that softening a mound that's been there for 200 years is essential to keeping the course relevant.  But if they can add bunkers and change greens, instead of just building new back tees, then they can pretty much do anything they want.

Michael Wolf

  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: Who governs interventions on the Old course ?
« Reply #5 on: February 07, 2022, 10:04:20 AM »
Also important to note that since 2004 the "R&A" which runs the Open championship has been a separate legal entity than the Royal and Ancient Golf Club of St. Andrews.

Niall C

  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: Who governs interventions on the Old course ?
« Reply #6 on: February 07, 2022, 12:08:52 PM »
Trustees’ Report for the year ended 31 December 2020


Introduction


The Trustees of St Andrews Links Trust present their Annual Report and Accounts for the year ended 31 December 2020. This report is prepared in compliance with the Charities Accounts (Scotland) Regulations, 2006 (as amended), Financial Reporting Standard 102 (FRS102) and the Charities SORP (FRS102) (referred to as SORP).


Reference and Administrative Information


Reference and administrative information is shown on pages 32 to 35.


Structure, Governance and Management


Governing legislation and appointment of Trustees. The Trust was established by the St Andrews Links Order Confirmation Act, 1974 (the “Links Act”), a private Act of Parliament.


The Links Act provides for the appointment of eight Trustees, three nominated by the ‘local authority’ (Fife Council), three by The Royal and Ancient Golf Club, and one by the Scottish Government. The eighth Trustee is the Member of Parliament in whose constituency the Links are situated. With the exception of the MP, Trustees are appointed for a three year term and are eligible for reappointment at the end of that term.


At their first meeting each year, Trustees elect a chairperson and are reminded of their duties and responsibilities under the Links Act and other charities legislation.


Trustee recruitment, induction and training


Although Fife Council and The Royal and Ancient Golf Club each appoint three Trustees and the Scottish Government appoints one it is important to stress that the Trustees are not in any way representatives or delegates of their appointing body. Newly appointed Trustees participate in an induction programme. They are provided with the latest Annual Report and Accounts, copies of past minutes and other background information and receive briefings on all areas of the Trust’s operations from senior management.


Governance


Day to day management of the Trust and its subsidiary companies is performed by a management team, headed by a Chief Executive, which reports to the Trustees at regular formal meetings, the minutes of which are published. Several committees and working parties exist to facilitate more detailed consideration of key aspects of the Trust’s operations.


Each of the wholly owned subsidiary companies has a Board of Directors which include a mixture of Trustees, members of the management team and, where beneficial, independent non-executive directors. The committees, working parties and Boards report to the Trustees at their formal meetings.


The Audit and Risk Committee is responsible for meeting with the auditors to agree the planning for the audit, reviewing the audit findings and the draft audited Annual Report & Accounts and approving them for submission to Trustees. They also review the Trust’s risk register and, if approved, recommend it to Trustees for adoption.


The Finance Committee is responsible for reviewing and approving draft budgets and pricing recommendations prior to their submission to Trustees for approval. In addition, the Committee was tasked with reviewing those risks regarded as financial risks and reporting back to the Audit & Risk Committee whether, in their opinion, they are adequately reflected in the risk register.


A Corporate Governance Committee is tasked with ensuring the Trust’s governance practices remain appropriate for an organisation of the Trust’s size and complexity.


A Remuneration Committee sets the pay and remuneration of the Directors having regard to various factors including performance, the movement in inflationary indices and benchmarking exercises with comparable sectors.


A Nomination Committee meets when required to select and recommend suitable candidates to fill Trustee vacancies.


A statement of the Trustees’ responsibilities in respect of the accounts is contained in the Reference and Administrative information on page 34.


Charitable purpose


The Trust is a registered charity and is therefore exempt from income and corporation taxes on its charitable activities. Trading activities which are considered to be out with the Trust’s charitable purposes are carried out by subsidiary companies, and their profits are remitted to the Trust under Gift Aid arrangements.


Related parties


Information on transactions with related parties is given in Note 22 to the accounts.


Objectives and Activities


The Trust’s principal objective, as stated in the Links Act, is to “hold and maintain the Links as a public park and place of public resort and recreation for the residents of St Andrews and others resorting thereto”.


St Andrews is famous worldwide, not just in golfing but also in academic and ecclesiastical circles and has a rich history. It is widely recognised as the “Home of Golf”, where the game began and largely evolved into its current form, is home to The Old Course- the oldest and most famous golf course in the world- and is renowned for its golfing connections.

Niall C

  • Karma: +0/-0
Re: Who governs interventions on the Old course ?
« Reply #7 on: February 07, 2022, 12:11:24 PM »
 Trustees’ Report continued for the year ended 31 December 2020
 
Many hundreds of thousands of people all over the world feel a strong emotional attachment to St Andrews and this bond raises the expectations of the thousands of visitors who flock to the town, many of them to fulfil a lifelong dream. Their expectations are high and the Trustees are acutely aware that only the highest standards of course presentation, facilities and service will meet or exceed those expectations. The Trustees’ vision is to develop continually St Andrews Links as the most renowned public golf complex in the world, delivering unique and memorable experiences for golfers to play, learn, shop and relax.
 
Locally, too, the Trust and the golf courses play an important role in the everyday life of the town. This is recognised in the Links Act which extends certain entitlements to residents of the town and to members of The Royal and Ancient Golf Club. The town is home to several long-established golf clubs and the Trust works with those clubs to facilitate their access to the courses for fixtures and competitions.
 
Historically, nearly 50% of all golf on the Trust’s courses is played by yearly ticket holders, R&A members and residents of St Andrews yet only a very small proportion of the Trust’s income is derived from these sources. The Trust depends on visitors for the great majority of its golfing and other revenues and it is therefore important, for both the Trust and the town, that the Trustees maintain an equitable balance between visitor and local play