Richard,
We all have our opinions and it is fun to debate. You don’t want to call anything that is unique but is manufactured quirky. That is your call just like I don’t like to call anything in GCA “unfair”. So be it.
What might be another interesting debate would be a thread titled:
“Bunkers should be found and not created.” So many architects try to build bunkers like those found on the original links courses. Makes no sense to do that does it especially in locations where there never would be a natural bunker