Overrated?? You mean from critics taking driveby pot shots and posting on YELP OR GCA.COM?
Pine Club's been doing it right since 1947, so for 74 years... (not counting the Covid shutdown period) I've only eaten there over the last 40 years and never pass it up if possible, but do miss conveniently grabbing some Skyline take-home down Brown street for quite a few years now... back when we lived in Lima...
Montgomery Inn in Cinti??
The Beef House in Covington, IN ??
When in Rome...