The 18th is a clear contender for finest finishing hole for PGA Tour Professional level matchplay ( or medal) competition. What's better?
It's a definite pucker tee shot and makes pros execute two solid shots. For 18th holes I like Oakmont, Winged Foot, Oakland Hills 510yd par 4 uphill, Pebble and Merion.
I don't get all the dislike for WS. It's as fine a venue as you will find for this type of competition. WS is maximalism at its finest and a beautiful place to spend 4+ hours. It's one of the most serene golf courses you will ever play.