Agree with everyone else who mentioned Bethpage Red.
Would love to be corrected, but it's hard not to think the Red punches way above its weight simply because it's the 2nd best public within 60 mins driving of NYC and because it sits in the middle of one of Golf Architecture's two meccas.
Like the Black, the greens on the Red are just flat out boring (9 might be the only exception). The bones are very much there, but it seems to suffer from some of the same long-term maintenance practice issues that plague the Black, especially the fairway mowing lines on holes like 9 and 13. For every great hole (1, 6, 13, 18) there's one that puts you to sleep while you wait 20 mins on the tee box (2, 3, 11, 14). Plus if you spend enough time at Bethpage, you'll get really sick of playing the same Par 3.
How about a plug for Belvedere in Northern Michigan??