It's okay for them to have an opinion of the courses, even if they're based on one play, and some of the opinions are skewed. Everyone gets to make the show they want to make.
In the early days posters here questioned whether Pacific Dunes was too easy to be considered great; NLU portrayed it as extremely testing because they played in a 30 mph summer afternoon wind. Sure, but that's pretty much true of any of the other courses there, except for possibly Old Mac because it has so much room.