Strong agreement with David and others (and please allow for innate Porthcawl member bias...), but RPGC has it, by a good distance. As I've mentioned before on GCA, that is also the dominant view within Wales, where the general ranking of local esteem seems to remain Porthcawl first, then Harlech and then Aberdovey, with Pennard in a decent scrap for fourth place. You may all think we're wrong. But as Tom Doak and others have often mentioned, repeated plays can give you a rather different perspective than occasional visits. Not necessarily better, but different. Anyway, all four remain, in their distinctive ways, wonderful places for a game of golf.
The above is a quote from Richard Fisher on the Pennard v Porthcawl thread and it was something that struck a cord with me. The locals often see things differently than visitors and wondered how the locals view differed to that of visitors in your area, and what the locals rankings would be compared to that of visitors ?
I'll give you mine after I've had a think about it.
Niall